Romney's Speech on Health Care

More

It was a close-to-impossible assignment: explain why the Massachusetts health care reform was good policy and President Obama's health care reform, so strikingly similar, wasn't. In his speech at Ann Arbor last week, Romney did advance the only principled defence of this position--which is that states can properly do things that the federal government cannot. Let the states experiment; don't impose one top-down solution. Moreover, you can argue, the Constitution denies the federal government power to make people buy health insurance; nobody, so far as I know, denies that this power is available to the states.

This federalist approach, as Romney called it, is a defensible position, and probably even correct as far as it goes, but it is plainly no use politically. Republicans do not want to hear key pieces of the Obama reform--the individual mandate, the exchanges, and so on--defended on their merits as attractive options for (some) states, or to be told that problems only arise when the feds get involved. They want to hear the policy repudiated in every possible way. They want to hear that the Massachusetts reform has failed.

Romney gave an engaging speech (as usual) and it was probably as effective as it could be. Had he disowned his own reform it would have been another insincere flip-flop, and that would have attracted even more criticism. He chose not to, and defended his reform pretty well. Even so, there were elements of trying to have it both ways. His discussion of differences between his reform and Obama's policy concentrated on inessentials, as it had to; the similarities are so much more important. He protested too much.

Also, an unresolved tension in his position became obtrusive. He advocates (a) state by state solutions, according to their very different needs and preferences (query: are they so different?) and (b) improved portability of insurance coverage from job to job, or from job to no job, as the case may be. That doesn't work. If portability is important--and it is--this argues for a national solution, or at least for state solutions that conform to a national template. The more you emphasize portability, the harder it is to denounce federal involvement.

Ross Douthat argues that Romney should just have disowned the individual mandate; this  would have threaded the needle, he argues. Yes, he could have done that. But you have to have the mandate (or a constitutionally permissible substitute) or else the plan fails, and for exactly the reasons Romney adduced in his speech. Ross also calls Romney's federalist position--that his plan is good, but states should be able to choose their own way--"horribly incoherent". Actually, despite the portability point, it is reasonably coherent. The problem is, it is bad politics, and if you are running for office that is what counts.

I cannot see how Romney gets past this issue. It's a shame. He is in many ways a capable and attractive candidate. And he is far more popular with the Republican electorate than you would expect, given that he is, in effect, an old-fashioned moderate. On health care, you could call him a conservative Democrat. US politics could do with more like him. It is tribute to his charm and tenacity that the GOP, intent on purging all RINOs, has not definitively spat him out already. But surely this is only a matter of time.

Jump to comments
Presented by

Clive Crook is a senior editor of The Atlantic and a columnist for Bloomberg View. He was the Washington columnist for the Financial Times, and before that worked at The Economist for more than 20 years, including 11 years as deputy editor. Crook writes about the intersection of politics and economics. More

Crook writes about the intersection of politics and economics.

Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

The Time JFK Called the Air Force to Complain About a 'Silly Bastard'

51 years ago, President John F. Kennedy made a very angry phone call.


Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Adventures in Legal Weed

Colorado is now well into its first year as the first state to legalize recreational marijuana. How's it going? James Hamblin visits Aspen.

Video

What Makes a Story Great?

The storytellers behind House of CardsandThis American Life reflect on the creative process.

Video

Tracing Sriracha's Origin to Thailand

Ever wonder how the wildly popular hot sauce got its name? It all started in Si Racha.

Video

Where Confiscated Wildlife Ends Up

A government facility outside of Denver houses more than a million products of the illegal wildlife trade, from tigers and bears to bald eagles.

Video

Is Wine Healthy?

James Hamblin prepares to impress his date with knowledge about the health benefits of wine.

Video

The World's Largest Balloon Festival

Nine days, more than 700 balloons, and a whole lot of hot air

Writers

Up
Down

More in Politics

Just In