Olympia's 'Betrayal'

snowe_-_alex_wong.jpgFor weeks, as the Senate Finance Committee moved toward a final vote on a health care reform bill, public attention focused sharply on a single member of that committee, Olympia Snowe of Maine.  That focus told us a lot about her: how she came to conclusions, what values motivated her, what life experiences had shaped her.  But now the question is not about Olympia Snowe but about her Republican colleagues.  We know a lot about Olympia; how other Republican Senators react to her departure from the party script will tell us a lot about them.

Most importantly, their reaction to Snowe's exercise of independent judgment will tell us how they see their own roles as members of Congress.  Is their loyalty to their party or to their oath of office; to the club they belong to or the Constitution they swore allegiance to?

To be clear, there are valid reasons to oppose almost every item in the Democrats' health care proposals just as there are sound reasons to support them.  What a constitutional democracy requires is not consensus but thoughtful consideration of alternatives and vigorous advocacy of differing views.  The question is how one decides on a course to be followed.  Democracy, after all, is not about policy but about process: not what policies one chooses to adopt but how important policy decisions are reached.  To this point, it is not a distinction many Republicans have understood.

Elected by her neighbors (the Constitution breaks from British tradition by requiring that members of Congress be drawn from specific constituencies with which they are familiar and in which they reside), Olympia Snowe has an obligation to consider the perspectives of those she represents.  Further, because ours is a representative, rather than direct, democracy, she has an obligation to evaluate as carefully as possible the options before her and to do, in the end, what she thinks is right (she need not follow her constituents' wishes if she concludes that they are not in the best interests of the nation she has vowed to serve; her obligation is to hear them out and take their views into account).  So long as the decision she reaches is constitutionally permitted, she will then have done her duty.  In this hyperpartisan world, however, some seem to believe her duty is neither to conscience nor constituent but rather to party.  And thus there is some grumbling among her Republican colleagues and suggestions that she should be denied a committee leadership position she would otherwise be entitled to claim on the basis of her Senate seniority.  The party that drove Arlen Specter from its ranks because he believed he owed the nation his best considered judgment rather than fealty to a political club now weighs whether to turn its betrayal-obsessed wrath on yet another in its circle.

Here's the thing.  One campaigns as a member of a party (Madison's warnings against parties -- permanent factions -- having been long since disregarded) but on election steps across an invisible line and becomes not a representative of a political faction but a part of the government sworn to serve the nation's interests rather than the cause of partisan advantage.  That may lead one to vote for or against a proposition, but for reasons other than, and far more important than, the desire to be true to one's team.  Olympia Snowe is guilty of no more than having taken her oath of office seriously.  It's something more of her colleagues should try.

(Photo: Getty Images/Alex Wong)

Presented by

Mickey Edwards spent 16 years in Congress and 16 years teaching at Harvard and Princeton. He is a director of The Constitution Project and wrote Reclaiming Conservatism. More

Mickey Edwards was a member of Congress for 16 years and a chairman of the House Republican leadership's policy committee. After leaving Congress, he taught at Harvard for 11 years, where he was voted the Kennedy School's most outstanding teacher, and at Princeton for five years. He currently runs a political leadership program for elected officials as Vice President of the Aspen Institute and teaches defense policy and foreign policy at George Washington University. He has been a weekly columnist for The L.A. Times and The Chicago Tribune and is a weekly commentator on National Public Radio. Edwards served for five years as national chairman of the American Conservative Union and the annual Conservative Political Action Conference. He was one of three founding trustees of the Heritage Foundation. In 1980, he directed more than a dozen joint House-Senate policy advisory task forces for Ronald Reagan's presidential campaign. He is a director of The Constitution Project and has chaired task forces for the Council on Foreign Relations and the Brookings Institution. He served on the American Bar Association task force that condemned President George W. Bush, and his most recent book, Reclaiming Conservatism, was published in 2008.

'I'm As Hardcore New York As You Can Possibly Get'

A short documentary about an electric violin player who busks in New York City's subway.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus


The Horrors of Rat Hole Mining

"The river was our source of water. Now, the people won't touch it."


What's Your Favorite Slang Word?

From "swag" to "on fleek," tweens choose.


Cryotherapy's Dubious Appeal

James Hamblin tries a questionable medical treatment.


Confessions of Moms Around the World

In Europe, mothers get maternity leave, discounted daycare, and flexible working hours.


How Do Trees Know When It's Spring?

The science behind beautiful seasonal blooming

More in Politics

From This Author

Just In