Beware the Idolatry of Numbers

statistics 2.JPGIn early August, The New York Times ran a front page story that statisticians--rather than "dronish number nerds"--are increasingly in demand, "even cool." With reams of data generated in the computer age and new realms to explore for purposes as broad as protecting national security or creating financial products, statisticians, says the Times , are only a small part of an army of "data sleuths...from backgrounds like economics, computer science and mathematics."

An important question raised by the story--and, of course, the broader, deeper trend of using mathematics and systems analysis to "understand" complex human behavior--is whether, before they have deleterious effects, emerging theories and products and ideas can be advanced with a strong measure of humility and put in the context of complex human society, where some key factors exist that cannot be quantified. Will the already potent but ever-emerging "numbers" class have the broad education and training to understand the "benefits" but also the "limits" of all this numbers crunching?

I raise this question of the potential effects of rigid application of mathematical and systems techniques because two of the most serious problems to beset this country--the Vietnam War and the financial meltdown--stemmed, in important ways, from overconfidence, indeed even cult-like behavior. These two problems are at the front of my mind due to two books that received attention in June and July that dealt with how the false idolatry of numbers and systems can lead people, institutions and nations far astray--with catastrophic results.

The first is former Defense Secretary Robert S. McNamara's, In Retrospect: The Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam. It was published in 1995, nearly 30 years after he left the Defense Department in 1968, but received much attention when McNamara died, at 93, in early July. As is well known, McNamara was a part of a World War II "systems analysis" team at Defense, led by Tex Thornton, a "whiz kid" who rose to the top of Ford Motor and a civilian technocrat who brought a powerful systems orientation to the Pentagon in the early 60s. While this approach certainly had relevant application to an attempt to rationalize the Pentagon's corpulent competition between the Army, Navy and Air Force, it became famous in the Vietnam War when numbers like body counts, targets hit, enemy forces captured, weapons seized, tons of bombs dropped, and hamlets protected were used to argue that the war was being prosecuted successfully. The origins of the war were not in systems theories (rather, to take one strand, a belief that monolithic Russian-Chinese Communism would overrun Southeast Asia). But those theories played an important part in convincing McNamara and President Johnson that the war could be won and, therefore, in deepening our involvement, resulting in tragedy both for the U.S. and for Vietnam

statistics.JPGThirty years later, McNamara declared in his book (positions repeated later in the award winning documentary, "Fog of War") that, although his aspirations were idealistic, "we were wrong. We were terribly wrong." Among his "lessons" about the causes of the Vietnam mistake: "our profound ignorance of the history, culture and politics of the people...[the failure] to recognize the limitations of modern high technology military equipment." After McNamara's death, the historian Michael Beschloss wrote: "McNamara knew little about Southeast Asia, and made no conspicuous effort to learn more. His penchant for numbers left him ill-equipped to understand that some human motivations cannot be quantified or predicted. As a result, he drastically underestimated the Viet Cong's determination."

The second book, Gillian Tett's Fool's Gold, is a detailed account of how a small group of bankers at J.P. Morgan in the mid-90s (many with degrees in math and computer science) developed product models--credit derivatives--and perfected methods of breaking those derivative products into small pieces, bundling the pieces and selling them--securitization. Tett is a well-regarded reporter at The Financial Times, covering global markets. And, while there have already been many important books written on the financial crash (one of the first being Charles S. Morris' The Trillion Dollar Meltdown), this is a very fine-grained account of what actually happened inside major institutions.

Presented by

Ben W. Heineman Jr.

Ben Heineman Jr. is is a senior fellow at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, in Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, and at the Harvard Law School's Program on Corporate Governance. He is the author of High Performance With High Integrity.

The Best 71-Second Animation You'll Watch Today

A rock monster tries to save a village from destruction.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

The Best 71-Second Animation You'll Watch Today

A rock monster tries to save a village from destruction.

Video

The Case for Napping at Work

Most Americans don't get enough sleep. More and more employers are trying to help address that.

Video

A Four-Dimensional Tour of Boston

In this groundbreaking video, time moves at multiple speeds within a single frame.

Video

Who Made Pop Music So Repetitive? You Did.

If pop music is too homogenous, that's because listeners want it that way.

Video

Stunning GoPro Footage of a Wildfire

In the field with America’s elite Native American firefighting crew

More in Politics

Just In