On Making and Taking, in Trenton and Around the World

By James Fallows

Yesterday I posted an item about a high-tech, clean-energy company in Vermont, under the title "Burlington Makes, the World Takes." Several people have written in to mention that this phrase is not original to me but in fact is the once proud, now bittersweet motto of Trenton, New Jersey, so prominently displayed as an illuminated sign on its bridge.

I know! I feel as if I have been conducting a fond, running homage to Trenton and its heritage with a series of articles and items under the Makes / Takes theme.

This series started long ago with a big Atlantic cover story called "China Makes, the World Takes." On the off chance that some of today's readers might not have memorized the full contents of this site since its inception, I'll point back to this item, six years ago, in which I explain one reason I love Trenton's motto so much. It's not simply the time-capsule value of the sign on the bridge, in expressing an American attitude of a certain era. It's also that one of my grandfathers, before his death in a car crash when barely in his 30s, had himself been one of the "makers" of the area. From that previous item:

The Makes/Takes slogan was adopted by the Trenton Chamber of Commerce nearly 100 years ago in honor of the countless small manufacturing firms in the area during America’s manufacturing boom of the early twentieth century. One of these companies was for a while run by my grandfather, Joseph Wilkes Mackenzie. Through the 1920s, the Mackenzie ceramics works thrived by producing the small ceramic insulators seen everywhere on power lines and telephone poles.

The company’s story has an unhappy ending. My grandfather died in a car crash in 1930, when my mother was three. Soon afterwards the company failed in the Depression, and my mother and her two older brothers had a rough upbringing (though she had a very happy later life). The larger saga of mid-Atlantic manufacturing took a similar downward course a few decades later. That sad story — what we’d now call a de-industrialization — is told by the derelict factories of New Jersey and Pennsylvania now visible along the same railroad line.

Inside Marriage Special Report bug
Reinvention and resilience across the nation
Read more

No doubt this background does something to explain why I am a manufacturing sentimentalist, and why my wife and I have noted the things we've found in Burlington and elsewhere on our American Futures route.

People of Trenton: I am not ignoring your role in crafting this slogan! On the contrary, I am honoring it, and looking for signs of the next American cities that can properly make a similar claim. 


The images above, and the one below, come from the wonderful Stangl Pottery site.

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/09/on-making-and-taking-in-trenton-and-around-the-world/280032/