McCain on Shahzad: No Miranda Rights? Really?

By Andrew Cohen

Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) continued his slow, shameful slide into political madness and legal contempt Tuesday when he declared that it would be a "serious mistake" for law enforcement officials to give a timely Miranda warning to an American citizen arrested in the United States for a domestic crime.

In reaching his unfortunate and premature conclusion, it's likely the senator was helped along by the fact that the citizen in question, Times Square car bomb suspect Faisal Shahzad, was naturalized just 54 weeks ago, is of Pakistani descent and was being investigated for foreign links. Evidently you can offer to trample upon the constitutional rights of a guy like that much more easily than you can the average Arizona voter. And of course there is a generally-supported "public safety" exception to the Miranda rule which federal officials chose to invoke for a period here before eventually reading Shahzad his rights.

Still, I would like to hear a fuller explanation from Sen. McCain about how far to the right he stands on Miranda from where once stood arch-conservative William Rehnquist, the late Chief Justice of the United States, who after a lifetime of conflict with the warning eventually came to tolerate and, ultimately, save it from extinction.  

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2010/05/mccain-on-shahzad-no-miranda-rights-really/56140/