In Defense of Nullification

We've talked some about William Stuntz' book The Collapse of American Criminal Justice. University of Pennsylvania law professor David Skeel was kind enough to do a couple short posts looking at two of Stuntz' more controversial proposals. The first is on jury nullification.

First of all, I want to thank you for inviting me to join your conversation about Bill Stuntz's new, posthumous book The Collapse of American Criminal Justice. As a friend of Bill's, I'm not completely objective. But I couldn't agree more that this is a hugely important book. One of the most remarkable attributes of The Collapse of American Criminal Justice is the counter intuitive solutions it offers to familiar problems. 

My favorite example is jury nullification--the decision by a jury to acquit a criminal defendant even if the defendant appears to have committed the crime. Although jury nullification is highly unpopular in most circles, Stuntz argues it actually was once a great virtue of American criminal justice, and that it would be a natural part of a healthier criminal justice system--a system that didn't incarcerate blacks at highly disproportionate rates. Let me explain. 

One of the key themes of The Collapse of American Criminal Justice is the decline of local democracy in American criminal justice. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the police, prosecutors, juries, and criminal defendants usually came from the same neighborhoods, especially in America's cities. Criminal defendants were neighbors, and jurors balanced their sympathy for the defendants' plight with their concern that their neighborhoods be safe. Not only were trials (rather than plea bargains) much more common, so were acquittals. 

In Chicago, Stuntz reports, defendants who killed someone in the midst of a bar fight or dispute over a card game nearly always argued that they had acted in self defense, and were rarely convicted. Although a variety of factors undermined this local democracy, one of the most important was white flight. In many cities, whites moved to the suburbs but, because they often remained in the same county as city residents, continued to vote for the city prosecutor and participate in jury pools. As a result, the citizens of the high crime urban neighborhoods from which many criminal defendants came had much less control over criminal justice than in the past. 

When the legal scholar Paul Butler wrote an article defending jury nullification in the 1995, the article was condemned as race-based and extremist. Stuntz disagrees. He argues that it seemed extremist only because local democracy has disappeared from American criminal justice. Restoring local democracy, and inviting some jury nullification, wouldn't be race-based at all, yet Stuntz believed that it would help reduce the tremendous racial disparities in our prisons. I think he may be right.
Presented by

Ta-Nehisi Coates is a national correspondent at The Atlantic, where he writes about culture, politics, and social issues. He is the author of the memoir The Beautiful Struggle.

How a Psychedelic Masterpiece Is Made

A short documentary about Bruce Riley, an artist who paints abstract wonders with poured resin

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus


How a Psychedelic Masterpiece Is Made

A short documentary about Bruce Riley, an artist who paints abstract wonders with poured resin


Why Is Google Making Skin?

Hidden away on Google’s campus, doctors are changing the way people think about health.


How to Build a Tornado

A Canadian inventor believes his tornado machine could solve the world's energy crisis.


A New York City Minute, Frozen in Time

This short film takes you on a whirling tour of the Big Apple


What Happened to the Milky Way?

Light pollution has taken away our ability to see the stars. Can we save the night sky?

More in National

From This Author

Just In