Hands Off College Language Programs


John McWhorter is usually an engaging commentator on language. So I had high hopes for his most recent essay, in The New Republic, on SUNY Albany's decision to discontinue French, Italian, Russian, and classics instruction. Unfortunately instead of defending his beleaguered fellow New York academics -- he now is with a think tank but is also a lecturer at Columbia -- Dr. McWhorter relegates Western European languages to "noble but fraying traditions." And he closes with clichés atypical of his writing:

The world is flatter and smaller by the hour. Our sense of which foreign languages are key to a serious education cannot be founded on what made sense for characters in Henry James novels.

I wish Dr. McWhorter had been in the audience when the noted scientific translator and historian Scott Montgomery spoke at Princeton earlier this month. One of the essential points he made is that while English is indeed becoming the global lingua franca of science, technology, and commerce, used as the original language of instruction and publication in many countries, governments and societies are simultaneously promoting their national languages. That means translation is becoming more rather than less important, all the more so since English is a "pivot language": a good translation into it can be retranslated into third tongues. While professional translation is still sadly underpaid, a multilingual person will always have an edge in understanding cultural nuances, and Europe remains a major center of technological innovation, selling us everything from advanced scientific instruments to high-speed trains.

Europeans are resisting cultural homogenization. National sentiment has been growing especially after the financial crisis revealed the underside of the euro. As for French, it continues to be the basis for a variety of global cultures, including some of the creoles that are Dr. McWhorter's professional specialty. And more U.S. students visit Italy than any other country but England, according to the Italian Language Foundation -- hardly a sign of undergraduate indifference.

There's no disputing the richness and strategic value of Chinese and Arabic -- and of Persian (of which we had shockingly few speakers in government in 1979), Urdu, and Korean, for that matter. And McWhorter is certainly right that non-Indo-European languages have special value in illustrating the varieties of speech. But he misses an essential point. Why do these other languages have to expand at the expense of the other tongues? Are there no other courses, administrative positions, or other expenses at SUNY Albany more deserving of cutting? McWhorter gives Russian study a mild imprimatur, but hardly calls for its restoration.

While I am not now, nor have I ever been tenured anywhere or at anything, plans for elimination of permanent positions in at a leading university can't be easily dismissed and must be reversed. Dr. McWhorter's class-baiting rhetoric -- "You know: two cars, a subscription to the Times, and mais oui, Caitlin knows some French" -- unintentionally echoes that of Princeton President James McCosh against relaxation of ancient language requirements by Harvard's Charles W. Eliot as pandering to clubby dilettantes, except that commerce and politics have taken the place of the Rev. Mr. McCosh's character building:

"I should prefer," he says, "a young man who has been trained in an old-fashioned college in rhetoric, philosophy, Latin, Greek and mathematics to one who had frittered away four years in studying a French drama of the eighteenth century, a little music and similar branches."

French, Latin, and Greek now coexist happily in universities. There's even a vigorous global contemporary Latin movement. Either-or thinking is boring. Dr. McWhorter is usually an original thinker. This time, au contraire.

Thanks to aldaily.com for the link to McWhorter's piece in The New Republic.

Jump to comments
Presented by

Edward Tenner is a historian of technology and culture. He was a founding advisor of Smithsonian's Lemelson Center and holds a Ph.D in European history. More

Edward Tenner is an independent writer and speaker on the history of technology and the unintended consequences of innovation. He holds a Ph.D. in European history from the University of Chicago and was executive editor for physical science and history at Princeton University Press. A former member of the Harvard Society of Fellows and John Simon Guggenheim fellow, he has been a visiting lecturer at Princeton and has held visiting research positions at the Institute for Advanced Study, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, and the Princeton Center for Information Technology Policy. He is now an affiliate of the Center for Arts and Cultural Policy of Princeton's Woodrow Wilson School. He was a founding advisor of Smithsonian's Lemelson Center, where he remains a senior research associate.

Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

Why Do Men Assume They're So Great?

Katty Kay and Claire Shipman, authors of this month's Atlantic cover story, sit down with Hanna Rosin to discuss the power of confidence and how self doubt holds women back. 

Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus


Where Time Comes From

The clocks that coordinate your cellphone, GPS, and more


Computer Vision Syndrome and You

Save your eyes. Take breaks.


What Happens in 60 Seconds

Quantifying human activity around the world



More in National

From This Author

Just In