Karl Rove should be forgiven for countering assumptions about Sonia Sotomayor's intelligence by claiming to know "lots of stupid people who went to Ivy League schools."  When Rove entered college in the late 1960's, stupidity was not necessarily a bar to an Ivy League diploma.  Admission was, in no small part, a function of social class, and schools maintained stringent exclusionary quotes for women and déclassé minorities, along with exceedingly generous affirmative action programs for white males, especially the children of alumni.
     Lots of people who graduated from the Ivy League in Rove's day (and mine) would probably not be admitted today.  I don't know if students who gain admission and garner honors in elite schools these days are smarter than their counterparts 30 years ago, but I'm pretty sure they're more accomplished.  So much more is required of them.
     Still, academic achievement only measures academic ability - not judgment, fairness, or honesty, obviously.  People who excel in highly competitive academic environments are not likely to be "stupid," at least not in the ordinary sense of the word, but they may be foolish, self-serving, arrogant, abusive, and utterly untrustworthy.  The complicity of so many presumptively smart, well-educated people in wrecking the financial system should surely make us wary of credentialism.
     But it seems to have lost none of its power, especially in the legal profession or the Obama administration.  Would the president choose a Supreme Court nominee who graduated from an obscure, third tier law school?  Not likely.  Graduates from lower ranked schools probably need not apply for prestigious clerkships either, as New York Times legal reporter Adam Liptak recently observed, quoting Justice Scalia: "By and large, I'm going to be picking from the law schools that basically are the hardest to get into. They admit the best and the brightest, and they may not teach very well, but you can't make a sow's ear out of a silk purse. If they come in the best and the brightest, they're probably going to leave the best and the brightest, O.K.?"
     The best and the brightest?  Scalia is old enough to remember that the late David Halberstam used that phrase ironically to describe the presumptively brilliant Ivy Leaguers of the Kennedy Administration responsible for the disastrous Vietnam War.  But he's not alone in his naiveté.  As Frank Rich observed months ago, people who should have known better repeatedly praised Obama's advisers and cabinet members as the best and the brightest, with no sense of history, much less skepticism.
     Not that you need familiarity with 20th century history to appreciate the dangerous deceptiveness of the halo effect conferred by prestigious degrees and reputations.  You need only consider the Madoff debacle and apparent, gross failures of due diligence by supposedly savvy, sophisticated investors, like Walter Noel, whose Fairfield Greenwich Group was Madoff's largest feeder.  Describe Noel's strengths, Frontline recently asked a former FGG sales assistant: "He had a degree from Vanderbilt University [in Nashville], and then he got his J.D. from Harvard ...His strengths are that he was very presentable..."  Ezra Merkin, who reportedly fed $2.4 billion to Madoff, for nearly $500 million in fees, is a Columbia College and Harvard Law School graduate.  Of course, Merkin and Noel may have assiduously avoided exercising diligence (their failures may well have been ethical, not intellectual) but whether victims or accomplices, their ability to attract the money they channeled to Madoff can only have been enhanced by their credentials.  Sometimes an Ivy League degree is just a pretty face, and sometimes there's a portrait in the attic.     

Jump to comments
Presented by

Wendy Kaminer is an author, lawyer, and civil libertarian. She is the author of I'm Dysfunctional, You're Dysfunctional, and a past recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship. More

Wendy Kaminer is a lawyer and social critic who has been a contributing editor of The Atlantic since 1991. She writes about law, liberty, feminism, religion and popular culture and has written eight books, including Worst InstinctsFree for All; Sleeping with Extra-Terrestrials; and I'm Dysfunctional, You're Dysfunctional. Kaminer worked as a staff attorney in the New York Legal Aid Society and in the New York City Mayor's Office and was awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship in 1993. She is a renowned contrarian who has tackled the issues of censorship and pornography, feminism, pop psychology, gender roles and identities, crime and the criminal-justice system, and gun control. Her articles and reviews have appeared in The Atlantic, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Newsweek, The American Prospect, Dissent, The Nation, The Wilson Quarterly, Free Inquiry, and Her commentaries have aired on National Public Radio. She serves on the board of the Bill of Rights Defense Committee, the advisory boards of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education and the Secular Coalition for America, and is a member of the Massachusetts State Advisory Committee to the U.S. Civil Rights Commission.

Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

A Breathtaking Tour Above the Moab Desert

Filmmaker Ian Cresswell rigs an HD camera atop a remote-controlled "octocopter" for some spectacular aerial views.

Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus


Where Time Comes From

The clocks that coordinate your cellphone, GPS, and more


Computer Vision Syndrome and You

Save your eyes. Take breaks.


What Happens in 60 Seconds

Quantifying human activity around the world



More in National

From This Author

Just In