The Conversation

Responses and reverberations
More

COMEBACK?

In a pair of articles for the December issue, Charles Fishman (“The Insourcing Boom”) and James Fallows (“Mr. China Comes to America”) examined why manufacturing is returning to the United States.

The analyses by Charles Fishman and James Fallows seem to be predicated on the odd assumption that the only two places where manufacturing occurs are China and the U.S. While it’s true that rising labor costs are making Chinese manufacturing cost-prohibitive, fortunately for U.S. businesses and consumers, the authors’ assumption is wrong. American companies are opening factories rapidly in Mexico, a nation of 114 million with relatively low labor costs, directly adjacent to the U.S. The continent of Africa, with more than 1 billion mostly poor and unemployed people, will become a practically unlimited source of low-cost manufacturing in the coming decades, as Chinese companies seem to have realized already. America’s time as a world-beater in manufacturing is long since past. The sooner academics, politicians, and, yes, journalists admit the truth, the better.

Carl Schwab
Arlington, Va.

Charles Fishman and James Fallows rightly point out the economic advantage of close proximity for design and manufacturing teams. It is also true that rising wages in China decrease that country’s competitive advantage. These factors tend to encourage our companies to manufacture in the U.S. However, if China is allowed to maintain a huge trade surplus with the U.S. by relentlessly manipulating our currency exchange rate, the U.S. manufacturing renaissance will be stillborn. In 2011, our trade deficit with China was $295 billion, which is the equivalent of about 7 million U.S. manufacturing jobs. China has caught up technologically. Its design and manufacturing teams are also in close proximity, producing Chinese goods that, with an artificially cheap currency, will continue to drive American companies out of business.

Thomas M. Tharp
West Lafayette, Ind.

Once upon a time, in the halcyon 1950s and 1960s, a man could have a blue-collar factory job and make enough money to support a whole family. Those days are over now, but they echo still in the dreams of manufacturing returning to the U.S. The idea is that were that to happen, good jobs would magically be created. Where the reality is that manufacturing jobs are not good jobs any more: you’re better off working in retail, whether you’re in the U.S. or in China. And you don’t need to spend unpaid years in college learning technical skills to get a retail job …

I do get worried when The Atlantic splashes the word “COMEBACK” all over its cover: that makes this phenomenon seem much happier than in truth it is.

Felix Salmon
Excerpt from a Reuters blog post

Mr. Fishman’s article was very interesting and optimistic, but he totally ignored the major reason for manufacturing’s outsourcing boom over the past 25 years: the elimination of import duties and quotas in this country. Prior to the near-elimination of tariffs, manufacturing in this country was protected from competition from low-wage-labor countries. As soon as tariffs were lowered and quotas eliminated, outsourcing became financially attractive. It’s interesting to note that conservatives’ resistance to cooperation at the UN is supposedly based on the perception that the U.S. would be ceding sovereignty, but they have no objection to allowing the World Trade Organization to determine U.S. trade policy.

Raymond M. Bodie
Fletcher, N.C.

I was surprised that government subsidies and tax incentives weren’t mentioned. GE pays little U.S. tax despite its significant profits. I understand that tax incentives and subsidies for the local manufacture of energy-efficient appliances—which do not always work as well as earlier, less-energy-efficient models—play a role in this. This may be taxpayer money well spent. But these measures are not part of a fair and rational manufacturing policy. As is the case with agricultural subsidies, the benefits are designed to go disproportionately to large companies, which have a seat at the table when policies and legislation are developed. Our life is made difficult enough by the pricing policies of the cartels controlling many of our raw materials without global companies getting the benefit of preferential tax treatment and government subsidies.

Robert T. Bateman
Oroville, Calif.

RAISING AWARENESS

In the January/February issue, Joshua Lang studied the terrifying problem of anesthesia awareness—when patients wake up during surgery (“Awakening”). He showed how efforts to eradicate the phenomenon have prompted deep questions about consciousness.

While intraoperative awareness under general anesthesia is extremely rare, one case is too many. Over the past 20 years, anesthesiologists have been committed to minimizing the risk of awareness. The Foundation for Anesthesia Education and Research recently issued $500,000 in grants to help fund research to clarify the role of brain monitors in the prevention of awareness. Although past research has shown deficiencies in recognizing awareness with monitors, researchers are currently applying new approaches and techniques to study consciousness, including those of Dr. Giulio Tononi, whom Joshua Lang profiled.

Before surgery, patients should meet with their anesthesiologist to discuss any past problems with anesthetics, including a history of awareness. Patients should also list all prescription and over-the-counter medications they are taking, so an anesthetic plan can be tailored to best meet their needs. If you believe you have experienced awareness, please talk immediately with your anesthesiologist, who can explain the events that took place in the operating room. The anesthesiologist might also refer you to a counselor. Early counseling has been shown to be effective in coping with awareness. For more information, visit LifelinetoModernMedicine.com.

John M. Zerwas, M.D.
President, American Society of Anesthesiologists
Richmond, Texas

As the inventor of the Bispectral Index (BIS), the consciousness-monitoring technology discussed in “Awakening,” I found Joshua Lang’s work excellent, as far as it went. But in certain critical respects, it did not go far enough.

Mr. Lang does a wonderful job introducing the reader to the complex issues around anesthesia awareness and consciousness monitoring, then highlights a clinical study, a case report, and a YouTube video that emphasize the limitations of BIS monitoring, and swiftly concludes that the technology “may still be clinically useful.”This is a remarkable understatement, at best. BIS monitoring is currently in widespread, everyday clinical use (more than 5 million surgeries annually) and has been the subject of hundreds of clinical trials and 3,000-plus scientific publications documenting improved quality and safety. Few medical devices in the modern era have been the focus of such intensive and extensive study.In addition, the scientific evidence supporting BIS has been reviewed by two of the world’s leading independent evidence-based review organizations, the Cochrane Collaboration and the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. Both organizations have provided clinical guidance documents in support of routine BIS monitoring, a distinction not many drugs or devices in broad use today can claim.

Nassib Chamoun
Needham, Mass.

The Benefits of Browsing

A writer calls Ann Patchett his “new hero” for fulfilling her town’s need for an independent bookstore (“The Bookstore Strikes Back,” December), and finds virtue in perusing the nondigital world—bittersweet commentary in light of the news that Barnes & Noble will close hundreds of retail locations over the next decade.

The WiFi has been down most of today at my house while we await an upgrade … This meant that I had to read the stack of magazines sitting by my chair. If I hadn’t done that, I wonder if I would ever have read Ann Patchett’s wonderful Atlantic essay about how she and her business partner defied conventional wisdom and launched an independent bookstore, Parnassus Books, in Nashville, where she lives, when two big-box bookstores closed down …

It occurs to me that I read [this] essay in a paper version of a magazine. I check in several times daily on The Atlantic’s Web site, but I don’t always see things there that are in the magazine. The Patchett essay is available on the site, but I’m not always going to see things like that, given my scanning habits. If you read an actual magazine from cover to cover, you’re going to run across things you might not otherwise see. Funny, but going to a bookstore, versus ordering online, is like that too. I’d say many books on my shelf at home are books I didn’t set out to buy, but ran across while browsing the stacks at a bookstore, fell in love with, and bought.

Rod Dreher
Excerpt from an American Conservative blog post


The most-read stories on TheAtlantic.com in January:

1. The Most Ridiculous Law of 2013 (So Far)

2. There’s More to Life Than Being Happy

3. IBM’s Watson Memorized the Entire Urban Dictionary

4. What van Gogh’s Famous Self-Portrait Looks Like as a Photograph

5. A Million First Dates

6. Awakening

7. The Day William Shatner Tweeted at an Astronaut

8. The High Price of Being Single in America

9. Why Parents Need to Let Their Children Fail

10. These Two Tax Charts Tell You Exactly Who Won the Fiscal-Cliff Deal

Jump to comments
Presented by
Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

Social Security: The Greatest Government Policy of All Time?

It's the most effective anti-poverty program in U.S. history. So why do some people hate it?


Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Adventures in Legal Weed

Colorado is now well into its first year as the first state to legalize recreational marijuana. How's it going? James Hamblin visits Aspen.

Video

What Makes a Story Great?

The storytellers behind House of CardsandThis American Life reflect on the creative process.

Video

Tracing Sriracha's Origin to Thailand

Ever wonder how the wildly popular hot sauce got its name? It all started in Si Racha.

Video

Where Confiscated Wildlife Ends Up

A government facility outside of Denver houses more than a million products of the illegal wildlife trade, from tigers and bears to bald eagles.

Video

Is Wine Healthy?

James Hamblin prepares to impress his date with knowledge about the health benefits of wine.

Video

The World's Largest Balloon Festival

Nine days, more than 700 balloons, and a whole lot of hot air

Writers

Up
Down
More back issues, Sept 1995 to present.

Just In