Brideshead Regurgitated

The ludicrous charms of Downton Abbey, TV’s reigning aristo-soap
Preposterous as history, preposterous as drama, Downton—now entering its third season—succeeds magnificently as bad TV. (Miles Donovan/AP Images)

At what point in the history of domestic service, I wonder, did lords and ladies start saying Thank you to their staff, instead of just kicking them into the fireplace? When did it begin, this treacherous acquisition of personhood by the dishwashing classes? Was there perhaps a single, pivotal moment, deep in some ancestral pile, when a purple-faced baronet looked upon his vassal and experienced—wildly, disconcertingly—the first fizzings of human-to-human recognition? Blame Saint Francis of Assisi. Blame Charles Dickens. By the early 20th century, at any rate, the whole master-servant thing was plainly in ruins. Individuals were everywhere. The housekeeper had opinions; the chauffeur had a private life; and the gentleman found himself obliged to take an interest, however slight, in the affairs of his gentleman’s gentleman. “And what will you do with your weekend off, Bassett?”

I know all this—lest you doubt my expertise—because I’ve been watching Downton Abbey, the ludicrously popular aristo-soap currently airing on PBS’s Masterpiece Classic. The motto of the show might be: “Footmen have feelings, too.” We are now entering Season Three, but really, everything you need to know about Downton happened in the first five minutes of Season One. Fans will recall the scene: Morning is breaking in 1912 England. Lawns twinkle under a fat old Edwardian sun. Upstairs, the blue bloods stir lazily in their four-posters; downstairs, uniformed menials scuttle in a fever of industry through the rooms of the great house, laying fires, opening curtains, bantering and reproving. They are building the set, essentially, for the pageant of privilege that is about to take place. A white and languorous arm extends; a bell is rung; down in the kitchen, an answering tinkle. “And they’re off,” says Thomas the footman, sneering into his porridge. Then the papers arrive: the Titanic has sunk.

Downton Abbey was created by Julian Fellowes, a sometime actor with a seat in the House of Lords and a wife who is a lady-in-waiting to Princess Michael of Kent. Preposterous as history, preposterous as drama, the show succeeds magnificently as bad television. The dialogue spins light-operatically along in the service of multiplying plotlets, not too hard on the ear, although now and again a line lands like a tray of dropped spoons. The acting is superb—it has to be. At the center of it all is the master of Downton, Robert, Earl of Grantham, played by Hugh Bonneville. Imagine Tony Blair stripped of that wolfish gleam of self-interest, inflated with 20 or 30 brisk strokes of a bicycle pump, squeezed into a tweed hunting jacket, and then sent out into the world with a fixed frown of genteel incomprehension. Bonneville has fine comic instincts (he was tremendous, for instance, in Notting Hill), and for the role of Robert he has cultivated a strange, plodding denseness and deliberateness, as if the earl is contending with a minor brain injury. In a sense, there is something wrong with Robert’s brain: his pomposity is so complete, it is almost a state of innocence.


Robert has an American wife and three lovely, impetuous daughters—but no sons, unfortunately, which means that as the saga began, the estate’s heir presumptive was an offensively middle-class person known as Cousin Matthew. Robert also has his staff: Carson, the pontifical butler; wise Mrs. Hughes, the housekeeper; selected maids of varying virtue; Thomas, a footman, chalky-white, a creature of the shadows, always sucking moodily on his cig. Then there’s Bates, heroic Bates, the valet, his voice a sexy and stoical rumble. Bates is loved by the lovely Anna (a housemaid), and hated by the hateful Thomas. The footman and his weird soul sister, the demonic lady’s maid, O’Brien—her hairstyle consisting of two ringlets perched on her forehead like horns—conspire against Bates. Soap, soap, soap, all foamily accelerated: births, deaths, Marxist chauffeurs, lubricious Turkish diplomats stalking the midnight chambers, every form of narrative contrivance whizzing and gurgling around the chandeliers of Downton—it’s like the ballroom scene in Ghostbusters.

Americans eat this stuff up, of course. Why wouldn’t they? Class in America is not the ancient, neurotic, and quasi-magical apparatus that it is in Britain. (As orcs and elves were to Led Zeppelin, a friend of mine once observed, so posh girls were to the Rolling Stones.) Class in America is a greasy pole: you go up, you go down. The closest thing this country has to Downton Abbey is the reality show Undercover Boss, in which a CEO descends, disguised, into the lower realms of his corporation, to wrestle with boxes in the loading bay and drop burger buns on the factory floor. He speaks searchingly (but not too searchingly; he must not blow his cover) with the minimum-wagers, nodding and grunting with slow-burning enlightenment: “Uh‑huh, uh-huh …” Then he zooms back up to the boardroom, to his leather throne, from which—in the big reveal—he spurts largesse over a couple of workers: a scholarship for this one, a lump sum for that one so she can get her family out of the homeless shelter. They cry, sometimes he cries, and thus are society’s inequities healed.

Presented by

James Parker is an Atlantic contributing editor.

Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.


The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.


Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.


Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

More in Entertainment

More back issues, Sept 1995 to present.

Just In