Letters to the editor

Changing Cityscapes

I suspect that many will be surprised by Richard Florida’s criticism of homeownership (“How the Crash Will Reshape America,” March Atlantic). Maybe it’s high time someone had the temerity to call this sacred cow a nightmare. There’s a problem, however: renting deprives millions of Americans of a goal that, since childhood, they have been taught is—like a college education—a worthwhile and achievable one. Homeownership validates their claim to membership in a class that has a tangible stake in America.

Hosea L. Martin
Chicago, Ill.

Future Fighters

Mark Bowden’s article (“The Last Ace,” March Atlantic) should have been titled “Ode to the Fighter Pilot.” Mr. Bowden made no reference to the best argument against spending untold billions for a full complement of F‑22s—remotely piloted aircraft, which make up a rapidly growing and capable segment of U.S. military air power. They are much cheaper to build and operate than piloted aircraft, primarily because they have no life-support systems. They can turn and maneuver more sharply, since g-forces are of little concern. And if a remotely piloted aircraft were to be shot down, there is no pilot to rescue. If these aircraft can perform as well as or better than manned aircraft, then the days of the fighter jock should be over.

Gregory Crowell
Cooperstown, N.Y.

As a physicist, I must point out that Mark Bowden’s article is plagued by a misunderstanding of the relationship between electrons and electromagnetic radiation (such as that used by radar). Electrons are not emitted by aircraft radar sets in any important quantities. If Mr. Bowden wants to write in terms of particles emitted and absorbed by radar sets, the correct particles are photons, the quanta of electromagnetic radiation.

John Caraher
Greencastle, Ind.

Mark Bowden replies:

Given the cost of combat jets, I figure just about any administration would prefer a viable, cheaper alternative that does not place pilots at risk. I suspect that unmanned fighters capable of modern air-to-air combat are in the U.S. Air Force’s future, but to my knowledge, no such aircraft yet exist that can rival a piloted fighter. The F‑22, on the other hand, is fully designed, tested, and operational.

Thanks to John Caraher and the many others who corrected my high-school physics.

Debating Gay Bishops

Paul Elie paints a sympathetic portrait of Rowan Williams (“The Velvet Reformation,” March Atlantic), but he does not seem to understand Anglican history and polity very well.

Henry VIII did not found the Church of England. He simply removed it from papal jurisdiction. English Anglicans have always been careful to insist upon the continuity between their Church and that of their pre-Reformation ancestors.

Additionally, although it would be nice if Williams had been “elected easily” to the primacy of the English Church, he was chosen by Prime Minister Tony Blair from names submitted by the Crown Appointments Commission. The queen made the formal appointment. The only election was a pro forma ceremony by the Dean and Chapter of Canterbury Cathedral.

John Richard Orens
Professor of History
George Mason University
Fairfax, Va.

Paul Elie misreads Archbishop Rowan Williams. When the archbishop of Canterbury says he doubts that there will be openly gay bishops in the Church of England in 10 years, he adds: “I doubt that we’ll have progressed that far in our discernment process.” Elie takes the quoted statement to mean “not yet,” and he’s confident that Williams is personally in favor of openly (and presumably noncelibate) gay bishops.

But the emphasis on Williams’s individual opinion is misplaced. The emphasis should instead be placed on the phrase discernment process. Williams honestly believes that as cantuar, and as a member of the Church Catholic, he is called to participate with others in discerning the mind of the Church, responsive to the will of God.

David Hein
Professor of Religion and Philosophy Hood College
Frederick, Md.

Paul Elie replies:

No, the archbishop of Canterbury is not elected by the bishops in the sense I suggested (though the many reports of Williams’s “election” confused the matter). But John Richard Orens’s other point is less a point of accuracy than a piece of polemic in disguise. As it happens, there was no Church of England before Henry’s. There was a church, founded in Jerusalem, centered in Rome, with adherents in the British Isles. The many points of agreement between Rome and Canterbury don’t alter the fact that Henry did create something new, nor the fact that in the name of the Church of England, the Roman Catholic Church was brutally suppressed.

Scholars are always saying that journalists lack subtlety about religion, but it seems to me that David Hein willfully misses the subtlety of my article. I don’t know what Rowan Williams thinks, only what he has said and written—and what he said to me in our two encounters at Lambeth Palace suggested that he would think greater openness to gay bishops a good thing. The quote at the end of the article bears this out: he, not I, spoke of gay bishops in terms of progress. My own view is that we shouldn’t have to guess—that the effort to discern what the archbishop of Canterbury thinks complicates the church’s effort to discern the right way forward about homosexuality. So I ended the piece by proposing that Williams should say what he thinks more forthrightly.

Miracle Drug?

I was very happy to learn that Virginia Postrel’s health-insurance company paid $60,000 for her Herceptin treatments (“My Drug Problem,” March Atlantic). But who really paid for these treatments? Her co-insureds or her employer.

Presented by

Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.


The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.


Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.


Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.
More back issues, Sept 1995 to present.

Just In