Fatah and Hamas

The Atlantic recently asked a group of foreign-policy authorities about the struggle in the Palestinian territories.
How should the United States approach the current situation in the Palestinian territories?
50% Work to engage and unite the two

“The U.S. and other countries need to pour money into the West Bank, to show there is an alternative in people's lives to the Hamas welfare state. Money should also be poured into Gaza through NGO channels (as should have been done, but wasn't, from the time that Sharon decided to withdraw from Gaza). Abbas should be pressed to reform his government; Israel should stop all settlement activity, release the rest of the PLA tax money it is withholding, and negotiate with Abbas a sensible route for the security barrier that minimizes separation of Palestinian villages and families. The U.S. (and the Quartet) should broaden Blair's mandate to include political issues or put in its own very high level negotiator (not just the Secretary of State episodically), and demonstrate that getting peace for Israel and a state for the Palestinians is an urgent priority, in our self-interest.”

“The U.S. made a grave error in keeping Hamas at arms length after its election victory. This has driven it into the embrace of Iran and other radical influences. A better approach would have been to accept its victory and engaged it with the aim of altering its policy toward Israel and bringing Hamas and Fatah together.”

“Isolating Hamas has failed and will continue to fail. Especially since its recent success in freeing the BBC journalist (something Fatah failed to even attempt, much less achieve), Hamas has growing credibility in Arab eyes. Separating the two halves of Palestine may be the Israeli strategy (myopic and cynical); but if the US adopts it for its own we shall just further weaken our standing in the region and be treated as a pawn of Likud.”

“Both Hamas and Fatah represent significant strains of Palestinian opinion and neither one will melt away, no matter how much either one is bloodied in street fighting. There will not be a clear victor. The 'two-state solution' of separate entities in Gaza and the West Bank reflects current reality and is a tempting basis on which to try to mount a new effort at building Palestinian institutions. An impoverished and isolated Hamastan in Gaza would be inherently unstable, however. A Hamas that is denied its goal of contending for power over all Palestinians also would still be a disruptive force in the West Bank.”

“…but this requires very skillful diplomacy and will be extremely difficult.”

“We should engage both, but I seriously doubt we can resolve the dispute and unite the factions. They have a struggle ahead and our uneven involvement will only distort the outcome.”

“The engagement of the U.S. and the international community is key to preventing the Palestinian territories from slipping further into chaos and violence.”

“Unity is unlikely, but engagement may produce some foundation that allows further work.”

“U.S. interests are clearly served by bringing both sides together, with Saudi and Egyptian help, leading to a deal—interim or full—with Israel.”

25% Treat Hamas and Fatah as two separate governments

“We should help Fatah to discredit and defeat Hamas, including by sanctions against those who help Hamas. Qatar, for example, is heavily funding Hamas and is paying no price for that policy.” 

“The Palestinian civil war is going to be decided by the Palestinians.  Washington doesn't have the standing to influence the outcome--at least not in a direction that favors U.S. Interests.”

“Engage supportively with Fatah as a separate legitimate government, and Hamas as a breakaway entity with no legitimate status.” 

“I’d stress ties with Fatah and keep lines of communications open to Hamas through the EU, and see if Fatah can remain viable.” 

“The United States should treat Abbas as the sole legitimate representative of all the peoples in the Palestinian territories. Hamas's 'victory' in Gaza represents an insurrection, not the emergence of a government or legitimate entity.” 

“Support Fatah as long as Fatah commits to reform/anti-corruption.”

16% Wait until a clear victor emerges

“It would be morally easy to say support Fatah; easy and terribly wrong. The U.S. has done far too much of picking winners and losers in the world recently; rather, it is up to the Palestinian people to choose an interlocutor, however flawed. Only then can any sort of peace deal stick, as it would be based on local legitimacy, and not whom the West prefers.” 

“Leave it alone. Let the conflict burn itself out. Interference delays the process.”  

7%Treat Fatah as a legitimate government and isolate Hamas (submitted independently by respondents)

“Engage supportively with Fatah as a separate legitimate government, and Hamas as a breakaway entity with no legitimate standing.”

“The U.S. should not do any of your three options, in my view.  We have an interest in the defeat of Hamas.” 

PARTICIPANTS (44): Graham Allison, Ronald Asmus, Samuel Berger, Daniel Blumenthal, Max Boot, Stephen Bosworth, Zbigniew Brzezinski, Daniel Byman, Warren Christopher, Wesley Clark, Richard Clarke, Ivo Daalder, Lawrence Eagleburger, Douglas Feith, Jay Garner, Leslie Gelb, Marc Grossman, John Hamre, Gary Hart, Bruce Hoffman, Laura Holgate, John Hulsman, Robert Hunter, Tony Judt, David Kay, Andrew Krepinevich, Charles Kupchan, John Lehman, James Lindsay, Edward Luttwak, Jessica Mathews, John McLaughlin, Richard Myers, William Nash, Joseph Nye, Carlos Pascual, Thomas Pickering, Paul Pillar, Kenneth Pollack, Joseph Ralston, Wendy Sherman, Anne Marie Slaughter, James Steinberg, Anthony Zinni.

Because of rounding, totals do not always add up to 100%.

Presented by

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus