Skip Navigation

Sun-Times vs. China Update (re. Va Tech shooting)

"Wasn't this pretty much what Orwell had in mind with the concept of the 'memory hole'?"

By James Fallows

The Chicago Sun-Times has altered the story by Michael Sneed mentioned in the previous post. Now there is an “explanation” about earlier suspicions pointing toward a Chinese suspect, rather than a Korean:

The initial investigation had led law enforcement authorities to a preliminary suspect who was a Chinese national, accompanied by details and a description. The man was placed on the suspect list before fingerprints could be verified. The list in turn was distributed to law enforcement officials via a national network in place to check on possible terrorism in the United States

I have no idea whether that paragraph will still be in the story the next time you, or I, or anybody else, clicks on it. This one link has, over the last 24 hours, connected to the following very different versions of reality, with no mention, in any of them, that the track record of the story was in effect being erased:

1) The original story that “identified” the killer as a Chinese student and caused near-panic in China;

2) A revised story, naming the killer as the Korean Cho Seung-Hui, and saying nothing at all about the previous Chinese claim (that is the version that prevailed several hours ago, when I wrote the previous item);

3) The current version, with its “explanation.” Of course the explanation does not mention that the Sun-Times and its columnist, uniquely among U.S. journalistic institutions, went public with information about the “preliminary suspect” as fact.

Conceivably some real explanation or mea culpa might have appeared in yet another version of the story that I didn’t happen to catch before it was changed.

Amending information in real time is a virtue of the web. Covering up one’s tracks is not. Wasn’t this pretty much what Orwell had in mind with the concept of the “memory hole“?

Bonus update: From a gun-enthusiast site, here is what appears to be the text of the original Sun-Times story, which seems to have been vaporized from the newspaper’s site.

James Fallows is a national correspondent at The Atlantic
Presented by

More at The Atlantic

The Case for Facebook The Case for Facebook
After 50 Years of Silence, China Slowly Confronts the 'Great Leap Forward' After 50 Years of Silence, China Talks About Its Tragedies
Oh Hey, Motorola and RIM Called: They Want to Go Back to 2004 and Try Again Flashback to 2004: Motorola and RIM Ruled the Phone Market
Video of the Day: An Illinois Lawmaker's Epic Freak-Out Watch This: An Illinois Lawmaker's Epic Freak-Out
Mario Batali on 'Sadistic' TV and Martha Stewart on Raising Chickens Mario Batali on 'Sadistic' TV and Martha Stewart on Raising Chickens

The Biggest Story in Photos

Olympic Portraits, Part I: American Athletes

May 30, 2012
No Gatorade: Celebrating New York City's Pick-up Basketball Scene
Watch More Video

On Newsstands Now

Subscribe and SAVE 59%
10 issues JUST $2.45/COPY

The Atlantic Monthly

David H. Freedman on smartphone apps and the perfected self, Mark Bowden on being in the dumb kids' class, James Parker on Glenn Beck, Isaac Chotiner on P. G. Wodehouse, and more

Browse back issues of The Atlantic that have appeared on the Web. From September 1995 to the present, the archive is essentially complete, with the exception of a few articles, the online rights to which are held exclusively by the authors.

See All Back Issues: September 1995
To The Present »

Premium Archive

For a small fee you can now access more than a century of Atlantic Monthly articles in our online archive. The archive includes articles from 1857 to the present.

Prices » | Login for Saved Items » | Help »

Sort by:
Dates:
From: 
To: 
Author:  (optional)
Title:  (optional)

Facebook

Newsletters

Sign up to receive our free newsletters

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)