Word Court



Newspaper reader

Hthat out of their reports? Initial ambiguities force the listener to decide upon the meaning, rather than perceive it clearly as the sentences proceed. Two of a number of examples I have collected: The Saudi group "demanded U.S. troops be removed" (the group wants U.S. troops -- oh, no, it doesn't). "He doubts many members would like it" (first he doubts the members, then their preference).

Richard Wendell Fogg


Ithat, encountering it so often, in fact, that it has begun to irritate me. Would not the sentence "Mr. Smith advised me that he would be departing next weekend and that he would return the following weekend" be better stated in this manner: "Mr. Smith advised me he would depart next weekend and return the following weekend"? Is there a rule of grammar or syntax covering this point?

Louis Candell

I have received other letters, too, about that in its role as a conjunction, in which it typically connects a subordinate clause to a main one. Mr. Candell, you'll want to know that by a margin of four to one my correspondents wish they saw or heard more of these thats, not fewer.

The magic of that is that at the same time it connects, it puts a bit of distance between two elements of
Newspaper readera sentence, a neat trick that often comes in handy. As Mr. Fogg's examples illustrate, sometimes one wants to make clear that the object of the verb is the whole clause and not the noun at the start of the clause, and that does this job with a minimum of fuss. Or one may want to put the distance between two (or more) subordinate clauses that express very different ideas. In the "Mr. Smith" sentences of Mr. Candell's, one that (after "Mr. Smith advised me") is surely enough, and I don't mind the version in which there are none at all. But I would add two to "Mr. Smith advised me he would depart next weekend and the roses need pruning," to make manifest that Mr. Smith advised me of two things, and disparate things at, well, that.

Where to prune that is either where ideas are closely related, as they are in the first "Mr. Smith" example, or where multiple thats begin to sound like a drumbeat: "He said that he had advised me that the departure that he planned ..."

SAtlantic, I was shocked to read the sentence "This isn't something that we can blame President Clinton for" in your response to one of the questions. Unless you like to leave participles dangling, the sentence would have been more properly worded "This isn't something for which we can blame President Clinton."



Scott Rupp


Now, hold on. "Shame on you" is considered polite discourse where you come from?

Oops. I mean, Now, on hold. "Shame on you" is considered polite discourse from where you come?

What's more (sorry, but you started this), that's no dangling participle; aren't you, rather, objecting to my having ended the sentence with a preposition? If so, kindly have a look at Fowler's Modern English Usage (any of the three editions), or Theodore Bernstein's The Careful Writer, or The American Heritage Dictionary, or pretty much any reputable usage guide, under "preposition at end" or "preposition," and see if this doesn't change your point of view. Good writers throughout the history of English -- from Chaucer and Shakespeare to Alison Lurie and David Lodge -- have not shrunk from ending clauses or sentences with prepositions. It isn't something that we should go out of our way to do, but if the alternatives that come readily to mind seem stilted, there's no reason to go out of our way to avoid doing it, either.


Newspaper reader

Wmilliner; I prefer haberdasher. Is there a gender-neutral term for someone who designs hats for males and females alike?

Daniel Arbelaez


How about hatter?

Have you recently had a language dispute that you would like this column to resolve? Write to Word Court in care of The Atlantic Monthly, 77 North Washington Street, Boston, MA 02114, or send E-mail to MsGrammar@TheAtlantic.com. All letters become the property of Word Court.

Barbara Wallraff is a senior editor of The Atlantic Monthlymagazine.


Illustrations by Terry Colon

The Atlantic Monthly; February 1998; Word Court; Volume 281, No. 3; page 120.



Presented by

Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

Video

Pittsburgh: 'Better Than You Thought'

How Steel City became a bikeable, walkable paradise

Video

A Four-Dimensional Tour of Boston

In this groundbreaking video, time moves at multiple speeds within a single frame.

Video

Who Made Pop Music So Repetitive? You Did.

If pop music is too homogenous, that's because listeners want it that way.
More back issues, Sept 1995 to present.

Just In