Interviews November 1996

Tracking India's Bandit Queen

A conversation with Mary Anne Weaver
More

In "India's Bandit Queen" (November 1996), Mary Anne Weaver reports on the remarkable story of Phoolan Devi, a poor village woman who was once the most wanted dacoit, or rebel, in India but who, after eleven years in prison, has now been elected to the Indian Parliament. Weaver recently spoke about Phoolan Devi with The Atlantic's Toby Lester.


You've been covering Phoolan Devi's story for thirteen years or so. What first drew you to her?

It was partly the myth, the lore, and curiosity about who she was. When I arrived in India [as a foreign correspondent] in 1982, no one knew anything about Phoolan's background. She was simply this woman who had allegedly gone into a village, massacred twenty-two men, and then disappeared into the ravines. Every now and then there were Indian and foreign correspondents who went off in search of her—always unsuccessfully—and maybe once a month there would be an item in the Indian press that said that Phoolan had been spotted in such-and-such a village, or had raided such-and-such a village. That she was a woman, of course, was the most interesting aspect of all this.

You write early on in "India's Bandit Queen" that Phoolan, "as a creation of the worst aspects of a monstrous social structure, . . . could lead a credible challenge against the caste system that has defined India since ancient times." How much of a role does the caste system still play in contemporary India? And does Phoolan's election into the Indian Parliament really represent a challenge to the system?

The caste system, nominally abolished by Gandhi and the Indian constitution, still has an immense influence on everyday Indian life. In the May, 1996, parliamentary elections the lower castes were reaching for power at the national level for the first time, and Phoolan is one of many low-caste politicians who came to power as a result. The Prime Minister of India himself, H. D. Deve Gowda, is a member of a lower caste. There's currently a surge of lower-caste politicians expressing themselves, and Phoolan is very much part and parcel of that.

It's a caste surge rather than a gender surge, then?

Definitely. Only a handful of women were elected in the most recent elections. Women in India are making great strides in the professions, but those making the strides are largely urban, educated women, not village women. In that respect Phoolan is a real anomaly. She is an illiterate, low-caste village woman who not only has survived a horrendous past—she survived all the horrors that happened to her before she became a gang leader; she survived all the horrors she allegedly committed as a gang leader; and she survived eleven years in prison without trial—but she also continues to survive in the urban jungle of Indian politics. And unlike so many women political leaders in formerly British India, her power is not a dynastic inheritance. She has achieved it herself.

Most of the nation appears to be very much on Phoolan's side—even at the most fashionable dinner parties in New Delhi the chattering classes are chattering endlessly about Phoolan. Her autobiography will probably be a best seller. She's a symbol of so many things—of defiance, of rebellion, of revenge, and of gender, although many Indian feminists would dispute this.

It has to be pretty frustrating for Phoolan to be playing a symbolic and political role after having been a dacoit. Is she comfortable with all the attention she's getting in her new position?

I think she adores it. When she threatened to immolate herself outside of a New Delhi cinema in February, in a protest at the premiere of a film made about her, she was furious—outraged!—because only one photographer showed up.

Phoolan, as you've portrayed her, seems deliberately to avoid identifying herself with one religion—she wears symbolic Sikh jewelry, talks about how others consider her a reincarnation of the Hindu goddess Durga, has a picture of Jesus sitting on her television, and consults with Buddhist monks. Is this behavior just a peculiarity of Phoolan's, or does it represent a means of self-empowerment for India's lower castes—who, as you point out, make up 85 percent of the electorate?

The Sikh jewelry, the picture of Christ . . . all of this is intrinsically Phoolan. However, what is happening, and has happened for many years, is that large numbers of the lower castes are converting to Buddhism and, to a lesser extent, to Christianity. Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar—a writer of the Indian constitution who was the most prominent leader of the former "untouchables" and whose portrait hangs in all lower-caste homes—escaped his "untouchability" by converting to Buddhism. Tens of thousands of others have done the same.

At several points in the course of reporting this story you were in the presence of people who claimed to have killed scores of people—the police officer Raghunandan Sharma boasts that he's killed 365 men, former dacoit Mohar Singh boasts more than 400 on his part, and Phoolan herself seems, at the very least, to have been behind the Behmai massacre. Has killing on this scale left distinguishable psychological scars on these people?

My assumption in the case of Sharma and Singh is that there aren't any deep psychological scars. Remember that dacoits are held in very high esteem in large parts of northern India. Every village—every family—wants one of its sons to become a dacoit; it is considered to be a very honorable profession. Singh killed a lot of policemen and Sharma killed a lot of dacoits, but that was, well . . . their job. It was what they were expected to do.

Jump to comments
Presented by
Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

Why Are Americans So Bad at Saving Money?

The US is particularly miserable at putting aside money for the future. Should we blame our paychecks or our psychology?


Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

The Death of Film

You'll never hear the whirring sound of a projector again.

Video

How to Hunt With Poison Darts

A Borneo hunter explains one of his tribe's oldest customs: the art of the blowpipe

Video

A Delightful, Pixar-Inspired Cartoon

An action figure and his reluctant sidekick trek across a kitchen in search of treasure.

Video

I Am an Undocumented Immigrant

"I look like a typical young American."

Video

Why Did I Study Physics?

Using hand-drawn cartoons to explain an academic passion

Writers

Up
Down

More in Global

More back issues, Sept 1995 to present.

Just In