The Problem With World 'Honesty' Rankings

The Reader's Digest honest-cities survey is a farce, so stop making slideshows of it.
This person's next step does not tell you how honest his city is. (Flickr/ misteraitch)

I'll admit, I'm just as into ranking the world's nations on various attributes as the next person. So I might be the last person you'd expect to come forward with a plea for caution on these things. 

Several international papers and sites' "most read" lists today had some version of the results from a recent Reader's Digest test that aimed to find the world's most- and least-honest cities. The magazine determined this by "dropping" 192 wallets—each filled with $50, a cellphone number, and other items—in major cities around the world to see how many people would try to find the owner.

The Finnish city of Helsinki was the most "honest," with 11 out of 12 wallets returned. Mumbai was second, with nine, and Lisbon was allegedly the least, with just one returned. 

And now, bring on the slideshows and the simplistic cultural explanations: 

"Finns are naturally honest," said Lasse Luomakoski, a 27-year-old businessman, who found one of the wallets dropped in the Finnish capital."We are a small, quiet, closely-knit community. We have little corruption, and we don't even run red lights." Another Helsinki couple in their sixties said: "Of course we returned the wallet. Honesty is an inner conviction."

No one loves praising Finland more than me, but if you look at the rest of the ratings, this tidy explanation simply doesn't hold up. Zurich, which is in rich, homogeneous, corruption-free Switzerland, scored on par with Rio de Janeiro, which is rife with inequality and crime. London is apparently less "honest" than Moscow, the capital of one of the world's most corrupt countries.

Digging deeper into stories about the test, it turns out some of the wallets were actually returned by foreign visitors to the country, which makes it less a reflection of the cities themselves than of the tourists who travel there. About a third of people in Zurich are foreigners. Meanwhile, about 60 percent of Mumbai residents live in slums, but the city is also home to towering skyscrapers and wealthy CEOs. Which contingent found the wallets, and did their economic situation influence their decision to call the owner?

Aside from the lack of information about who found each city's wallets, and where, there's also the issue that "honesty" doesn't mean the same thing in every country. Someone who finds a wallet in Spain—where the unemployment rate is 27 percent—might see keeping the $50 just as a way to buy food that day, not as an act of malice.

Granted, Reader's Digest isn't exactly a peer-reviewed journal or a polling organization, and it can do whatever experiments it wants. But news organizations shouldn't report this like it's a true representation of relative ethics worldwide. It would certainly be interesting to find out which cities are actually the most honest—maybe by coming up with culturally specific questions and having trained researchers administer them to a random sample of people who represent the full demographic range in each country. But this isn't that, so saying Lisbon is the "least honest" city is, well, dishonest.

Presented by

Olga Khazan is a staff writer at The Atlantic, where she covers health.

What Happened to the Milky Way?

Light pollution has taken away our ability to see the stars. Can we still save the night sky?

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

What Happened to the Milky Way?

Light pollution has taken away our ability to see the stars. Can we still save the night sky?

Video

The Faces of #BlackLivesMatter

Scenes from a recent protest in New York City

Video

Desegregated, Yet Unequal

A short documentary about the legacy of Boston busing

Video

Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Life

The Supreme Court justice talks gender equality and marriage.

Video

Social Media: The Video Game

What if the validation of your peers could "level up" your life?

Video

The Pentagon's $1.5 Trillion Mistake

The F-35 fighter jet was supposed to do everything. Instead, it can barely do anything.

More in Global

Just In