China to Web Users: Great Firewall? Just Be Glad We're Not North Korea

The country's state-controlled media is telling Web-surfers they could have it much worse -- but the users aren't buying it.

china google banner2.jpg
Christina Hu/Reuters

Last week, Google Executive Chairman Eric Schmidt urged North Korean leaders to embrace the Internet. Only a small proportion of that country's 24 million people can access the World Wide Web, and the majority of the 1.5 million mobile phones there belong to political and military elites.

Meanwhile, in China, a country that has embraced the Internet to a much greater extent, the big story was about censorship, both online and off. Reporters and local citizens protested propaganda authorities' decision to re-write newspaper Southern Weekly's planned New Years editorial on constitutionalism. Discussions about the topic were deleted on China's microblogs and online forums. As a result, images and wordplay in support of Southern Weekly filled the blogosphere.

In the midst of the hubbub, China Central Television (CCTV), the state-controlled behemoth, filed a report about the state of Internet freedom in North Korea on January 10, and tweeted a summary on Sina Weibo, the leading microblog service provider:

Things that we consider trivial and normal like going online, sending emails, and downloading software on an iPad are considered 'privileges' in North Korea. Only a few people are permitted to visit foreign websites because of the needs of their work, and the majority of people can only visit domestic websites. Sending and receiving emails requires an even more complex set of approvals. Even PC tablet devices, which quickly sold out [in North Korea], do not have online capability and cannot download software.

For Chinese social media users, the irony here was too perfect to go unnoticed. @孤翔2012 responded: "In China, too, only the privileged can visit Facebook. Don't be the 'pot calling the kettle black.'" In a similar vein, @拉风特产 commented: "Why are we criticizing others when we should be examining ourselves? How many famous global websites are we able to visit? It is embarrassing to say."

A number of social networking and sharing websites are blocked in China, including Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, Wikipedia, and certain Google applications. From time to time, Chinese authorities have also blocked access to news publications in retaliation for unfavorable reporting.

Web users' responses to the CCTV post comparing China and its Communist neighbor are interesting for two reasons. First, they capture a shifting baseline of comparison, which contribute to peoples' understanding of themselves and their environment. Second, particularly in the broader context of last week's Southern Weekly controversy, the responses highlight how patterns of communication are changing. Both have implications for people's expectations for dialogue and participation.

Shifting Baselines of Comparison

Web users are citizens of the world. They are quick to compare everything from Internet speed to freedom of speech with their international peers. One of the most common complaints in China is about Internet speed. "Damn! Last time I was in the Seoul airport - that was [expletive] fast!" exclaimed @花古朵. "It's so simple for [other countries' networks] to exceed China's Internet speed," added @亚茉莉. Globalization coupled with the World Wide Web has made the norms of developed countries more apparent than ever to a massive and growing population of Chinese Internet users and, increasingly, to people located in the country's less developed interior.

The Communist Party and nationalist media take a nuanced approach to international comparisons. The official narrative goes something like this: "China's progress must be viewed in the context of its unique historical and cultural circumstances. There may be a time and place for unfettered and free flow of ideas, but China has not yet reached that phase of its social development." This official approach favors selective comparisons. Chinese citizens are urged to take comfort because freedom of expression and the press is relatively greater than it was just decades ago. And, as with CCTV's report, official media is happy to point out China's freedom compared to closed societies like North Korea.

Presented by

David Caragliano is a lawyer and international development professional based in Washington, DC, and a contributor to Tea Leaf Nation.

Never Tell People How Old They Look

Age discrimination affects us all. Who cares about youth? James Hamblin turns to his colleague Jeffrey Goldberg for advice.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


Never Tell People How Old They Look

Age discrimination affects us all. James Hamblin turns to a colleague for advice.


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.


Pittsburgh: 'Better Than You Thought'

How Steel City became a bikeable, walkable paradise


A Four-Dimensional Tour of Boston

In this groundbreaking video, time moves at multiple speeds within a single frame.


Who Made Pop Music So Repetitive? You Did.

If pop music is too homogenous, that's because listeners want it that way.

More in Global

Just In