Skip Navigation
J.J. Gould

J.J. Gould - J.J. Gould is deputy editor of TheAtlantic.com.
More

J.J. Gould is deputy editor of TheAtlantic.com. He has previously worked as an editor with McKinsey & Company's New York-based Knowledge Group, where he focused on global public- and social-sector development, the economics of carbon-emissions reduction, and issues in the media industry; an editor at the Journal of Democracy, co-published by the Johns Hopkins University Press and the National Endowment for Democracy; and a lecturer in history and politics at Yale University. He has written for The Washington Monthly, The American Prospect, The Moscow Times, The European Journal of Political Theory, and other publications; he also co-wrote and co-produced the independent film The Chinese Room. Gould has a B.A. in history from McGill University in Montreal, an M.Sc. from the London School of Economics, and a Ph.D. in in politics from Yale. Originally from Nova Scotia, he lives with his family outside Washington, D.C.

New at The Atlantic: The Democracy Report

By J.J. Gould
Feb 28 2011, 10:55 PM ET Comment

An unexpected wave of democratization reshaped our world not so long ago. Could it happen again now?

5378711868_18390833e0_b-1 a.jpg

When Portugal scrapped its dictatorship during the Carnation Revolution of 1974, and through months of political turmoil afterward, it was never obvious that the country would end up democratic: Portugal never been so before; in fact, for most of the 20th century it had been authoritarian. Immediately next door, in Spain, Francisco Franco's authoritarian regime seemed fine. Journalists, intellectuals, and academics throughout the West broadly assumed, meanwhile, that the whole Iberian peninsula and most of Latin America weren't fit for democracy on account of their Latin-Catholic societies. Similar ideas about Asia's and Africa's suppposed cultural incompatibility with democratic rule were widespread.

The Democracy ReportAt the time of the Carnation Revolution, only 41 of the world's then-150 states were democracies, and most of these were first-world, advanced-industrial economies. But after Portugal pulled off its big democratic transition in the mid-'70s, Greece and Spain followed, leading to to what Samuel Huntington called the "third wave" of democratization globally: During the '80s, civilian governments took over from military rulers across Latin America, eventually including Chile; Ferdinand Marcos's dictatorship fell in the Philippines; military rule ended in South Korea; and martial law was lifted in Taiwan, beginning a ten-year democratic transition there. By 1990, between the fall of the Berlin wall and the collapse of the Soviet Union, most Eastern European countries were holding meaningful elections. Also in 1990 -- the year a watershed democratic transition got underway in Benin, and the same year Nelson Mandela was released from prison in Apartheid South Africa -- there were just three democracies on the African continent; only seven years later, the majority of African states were holding competitive elections, too. Here and in other areas of the world hit by the third wave, there's been ideological resistance, endemic corruption, and daunting regression offsetting the advance of democracy. But of the almost 200 states in existence around the world today, 123 are democratic, and no form of government has anything close to the broad global legitimacy theirs does. (For more, see Larry Diamond's "Universal Democracy?")

Until now, one part of the world has remained mainly unmoved by this current: North Africa and the Middle East (Israel, Lebanon, and our own attempts to engineer democratization in Iraq over the last decade notwithstanding). That seemed maybe to be changing in 2009, with Iran's Green Revolution. And it appears decisively to be changing now -- in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, and potentially across the region. No, none of the countries affected by today's pattern of fast-replicating protest movements is obviously in the midst of a real transition to democracy, and we can't yet tell how close to one any of them might be. In some cases, as in Yemen, it's not even clear that anti-government agitation will organize itself in terms of democratic goals at all. And it remains entirely possible that the regional momentum building since the outset of this year's Jasmine Revolution in Tunisia will stall, or that the democratic hopes driving this momentum will end up crushed, whether abruptly by force or gradually by political failure.

Still, at The Atlantic, the frame of democracy is unavoidable in the way we look at the broader story around these uprisings. This isn't just because the story is ultimately tough to scope in regional or cultural terms -- though it is: It's North African but also Middle Eastern; it's Arab but also Berber and Persian; it's Muslim but also secular. And it's not just because the story is ultimately impossible to imagine apart from its global history -- though it's that, too: Without the third wave having normalized democratic ideas internationally, and without the proliferation of Western social media, we wouldn't have the Arab social movements we now have. It's also because the story is already affecting global events as much as it's been affected by them: While the idea of democracy has rapidly gone from a latent aspiration among Arab peoples to a manifest threat to Arab political orders, Arab mass protest movements have almost as rapidly created powerful demonstration effects, influencing others not just throughout the region but around the world -- including scenes as geographically remote as Zimbabwe and China.

From the escalation of protests in Tunisia, through the revolution in Egypt, the current crisis in Libya, and the ongoing demonstrations in Yemen, Bahrain, and elsewhere, to the unprecedented ways in which social technology has changed the political game in country after country, The Atlantic has been on the regional story in the Middle East and North Africa with some of the sharpest and most creative reporting and analysis we have going. As of today, we've also launched a special section at TheAtlantic.com, The Democracy Report, bringing this coverage together from across our channels (International, Technology, Politics, and others). So check back, read around, and stay with the discussion -- down in the comments, on Facebook, or on Twitter.

Image: freestylee/Flickr


Presented by

More at The Atlantic

Hey Voters: The Kill List Is What Matters Hey Voters: President Obama's Kill List Is What Matters
After 50 Years of Silence, China Slowly Confronts the 'Great Leap Forward' China Confronts the Great Leap Forward
Why Are Democrats Losing the Wisconsin Recall? Why Are Democrats Losing the Wisconsin Recall?
The Edwards Trial: A Bad Idea From Before the Start The Edwards Trial: A Massive Waste of Time
10 Years After Its Premiere, 'The Wire' Feels Dated, and That's a Good Thing A Decade Later, 'The Wire' Feels Dated, and That's a Good Thing

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.
blog comments powered by Disqus
View All Correspondents

The Biggest Story in Photos

The Unreal World

May 31, 2012

Subscribe Now

SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY

Facebook

Newsletters

Sign up to receive our free newsletters

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)