Why I Changed My Mind on the Food Stamps for Soda Ban

By Marion Nestle

A nutritionist explains that although she doesn't like telling people what to eat, soda's health risks make regulating it a good idea

4199481962_8cacfaaa49_b_wide.jpg

Recently I received an e-mail query from Jan Poppendieck, author of three truly outstanding books that I often use in classes:

Q. I am collecting opinions on the proposal to ban use of SNAP (food stamp) funds for buying sodas. What do you think of that idea?

A. I started out deeply uncomfortable with the idea of the soda ban but I now support it. The discomfort came from my general discomfort with telling people what I think they should be eating. I never comment on what individuals eat (and I hope you won't comment on what I eat). My work deals with nutrition for populations, not necessarily individuals. So banning sodas at first seemed to me to be too personal an approach.

But I changed my mind for several reasons:

  • The increasingly strong evidence that sugary drinks predispose to obesity
  • The disproportionately higher rates of obesity among the poor
  • The suggestive evidence that sugars in liquid form are especially predisposing to obesity
  • The comparison of the SNAP approach (the benefits can be used for most any food) with that of Women, Infants and Children (WIC) (the benefits only work for a restricted number of foods)
  • The focus of soda companies on marketing to children and youth in low-income areas
  • The lack of grocery stores in low-income areas
  • The intense marketing of sodas to children and youth in developing countries
  • The increasingly successful efforts of soda companies to co-opt health professional groups with partnerships, alliances, and grants
  • The astonishing amount of money and effort used by beverage companies and associations to fight soda taxes and, no doubt, this idea as well

Soft drink companies have gotten a free ride for years. They moved into schools and created an environment that makes it socially acceptable for children to drink sodas all day long. If sodas are now under scrutiny for their role in obesity, it is because soda companies are reaping what they have sown.



This post also appears on Food Politics.
Image: avlxyz/flickr

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2011/04/why-i-changed-my-mind-on-the-food-stamps-for-soda-ban/237483/