The oceans are in serious trouble, lakes aren't in great shape either, and those of us who like seafood because we enjoy the taste are losing out. The salmon I tasted is grown under positive environmental circumstances. But is growing bland seafood a good thing?She picks the two commonest farmed fish to concentrate on, and the ones most telling: salmon and tilapia. I long ago took a proudly harsh stand against ever, ever eating farmed salmon, as I wrote about when I visited Alaska to watch really good and well-managed wild salmon be fished, cleaned, and shipped:
Farmed Atlantic salmon, which in just twenty-five years has overtaken the world market, is almost always mushy, bland, flabby--criminally dull. I gave up ordering it several years ago, when I decided that no amount of pineapple salsa could render it acceptable, let alone enjoyable.Since I wrote the piece, I've encountered several pieces of edible farmed salmon, two from Scotland and one from Norway. That's pretty much it. And as a restaurant reviewer, I have to eat my share, ever-hopeful and ever vigilant to order salmon during permissible harvest season, roughly from the beginning to the end of summer.
But that changes every year. Last year the California and Oregon salmon fisheries collapsed. This year the long battle over four dams on the Snake River, which James Fallows wrote about in our pages, has gotten noisy again, with new calls for the Obama administration to breach at least a few of the dams to allow salmon to return to their spawning grounds--rather than trucking them around the dams, a silly solution, as the Los Angeles Times pointed out last month. But the administration's report, released last week, didn't call for measures nearly as strong as environmentalists had hoped.
So farmed salmon, for all its environmental and culinary faults, will still be the only alternative out of season. But legal season is still open! And this year the catch has been strong, and I came away from my Alaska trip convinced that the fishery is well-managed.
That doesn't help most of the world get sustainable protein with all the benefits we keep hearing omega-3s offer. Is the rest tofu of the sea, as a friend of York's memorably calls tilapia? Yup. Except, as she says, oysters and mussels, which I enjoy too, and perhaps naively trust more--not that you effectively have much choice anymore, particularly when it comes to mussels (the best farmed I've had are from Prince Edward Island).
While environmentalists call for a moratorium on much salmon fishing, I'll keep up my personal moratorium on eating farmed salmon--but rely on people like York, who make significant buying decisions, to keep tasting and keep hoping.
This article available online at: