My skepticism was unnecessary, because in spite of its ingredients (fries, cheese curds, gravy) and appearance (this is going to hurt), poutine is a dish that doesn't have to be over the top or lacking in nuance. When the fries are done right, the gravy good, and the curds fresh, it can be a delightful dish that doesn't feel like it's going to kill you. Over the last week, we got to try three poutines, each of them at a place where they are renowned to be done right. I visited the top three from our poutine poll: La Banquise (29 percent of the votes), Au Pied de Cochon (19 percent), and Patati Patata (16 percent).
The chef/waiter behind the counter recommended the patatine, which takes the basic poutine and adds olives, onions, mushrooms, and a few peppers. My traveling companions sampled the basic poutine, so I was able to try both.
The fries are twice-fried, which I always appreciate, and hold their texture surprisingly well under the gravy, which doubles as the dish's seasoning of salt (it's made from chicken stock, and it's delicious). The curds add a cheese flavor without making the fries soggy, which strikes me as an evolutionary step for cheese fries. While the basic poutine was great, I was grateful for the recommendation of the patatine variation with the vegetables, which not only took some of the guilt away but also added some brightness to the dish.
The next poutine really worried me, the foie gras version at Au Pied de Cochon:
How do you take a dish of fries, curds, and gravy, and add seared foie gras to it without it becoming a gloppy, unctuous mess? I'm not sure you do. I had to embrace the mess, and I'm glad I did. Cochon's gravy is a winner, made with both chicken and beef stock, and the fries (as you can see in the photo) were that perfect golden brown. If you want the basic poutine, that's on the menu as well, or you can get just the fries. But this is not a restaurant that encourages moderation, and you may find it difficult (as I did) to say no to the foie gras poutine. (And thanks to reader dustographic for urging me to try it.)
La Banquise, the winner of the poll, was a lot of fun: a 24-hour poutine destination, with over two dozen different variations of poutine. We had the Galvaude--shredded chicken and peas in addition to the standard gravy and curds (thanks to readers david and squeezebottle for recommending it)--and the Matty, which was adorned with bacon, peppers, mushrooms and sauteed onions. (It was too dark for my pictures to come out, unfortunately.) Both were good poutines, and would make for an ideal meal right after the bars close.
So which did I think was best? For me, they were all winners. I liked the gravy best at Patati Patata, I liked the fries best at Au Pied de Cochon, and I liked the variety best at La Banquise.
Many thanks for participating, and stay tuned for a results from the "Montreal Bistros on a Budget" poll.
Next up: Terrence travels to Boston for one night only. Vote on where he should eat dinner and breakfast while he's there, and check back for a poll on the best food New York City.