On My Bookshelf: Silent Cal and International Justice

By Conor Friedersdorf

In recent years, Calvin Coolidge has enjoyed a resurgence in popularity among small government conservatives. What follows is a passage on foreign affairs from his inaugural address dated 4 March 1925.

There is much to be hoped for in international relations from frequent conferences and consultations... Even the failures can not but be accounted useful and an immeasurable advance over threatened or actual warfare. I am strongly in favor of continuation of this policy, whenever conditions are such that there is even a promise that practical and favorable results might be secured.

In conformity with the principle that a display of reason rather than a threat of force should be the determining factor in the intercourse among nations, we have long advocated the peaceful settlement of disputes by methods of arbitration and have negotiated many treaties to secure that result. The same considerations should lead to our adherence to the Permanent Court of International Justice. Where great principles are involved, where great movements are under way which promise much for the welfare of humanity by reason of the very fact that many other nations have given such movements their actual support, we ought not to witthold our own sanction because of an small and inessential difference, but only upon ground of the most important and compelling fundamental reasons.

We can not barter away our independence or our sovereignty, but we ought to engage in no refinements of logic, no sophistries, and no subterfuges, to argue away the undoubted duty of this country by reason of the might of its numbers, the power of its resources, and its position of leadership in the world, actively and comprehensively to signify its approval and to bear its full share of the responsibility of a candid and disinterested attempt at the establishment of a tribunal for the administration of even-handed justice between nation and nation. The weight of our enormous influence must be cast upon the side of a reign not of force but of law and trial, not by battle but by reason. ~ from Inaugural Addresses, W.H Taft to G.W. Bush    

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2011/04/on-my-bookshelf-silent-cal-and-international-justice/236982/