The Need for (and Fun-Sucking Potential of) Instant Replay in Baseball

This year's World Series has had enough controversial calls to make a case for the MLB stepping into the 21st century. But will the game still need old-fashioned judgment calls?
Boston Red Sox relief pitcher Koji Uehara, rear, and catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia celebrate the Red Sox 5-2 win over the Detroit Tigers on Oct. 19. The Red Sox advance to the World Series. (AP; Matt Slocum)

Hampton Stevens (writer, ESPN and The Atlantic), Patrick Hruby (writer, Sports on Earth and The Atlantic), and Jake Simpson (writer, The Atlantic) discuss the World Series:


Simpson: All right, here we go...

OBSTRUCTION!! PICKOFFS!! CONTROVERSY!! IT'S THE 2013 WORLD SERIES, BROUGHT TO YOU BY THE RINGLING BROTHERS!

What a quintet of games we've had so far in the Fall Classic. The Red Sox and Cardinals have battled to a near stalemate in a taut set of games, with Boston taking a 3-2 series lead back to Fenway Park after Monday's 3-1 victory.

The series has had enough circus-like plays and controversy to fill a decade of October baseball. St. Louis won Game 3 on a walk-off obstruction call, the first game in the 110-year history of the World Series to end that way. Boston won Game 4 on a pickoff, of all things, also a Fall Classic first. It's amazing that Monday's game didn't end with a dropped third strike, or a swarm of midges descending on the field.

The offensive star thus far has been David Ortiz, who's put up video-game numbers in a otherwise pitcher-friendly series. Ortiz is hitting an absurd .733 with a 1.267 slugging percentage in five games and would have even better numbers if Carlos Beltran hadn't robbed him of a grand slam in Game 1. 

While Big Papi has been the biggest player in the series, the biggest issue has been the many disputed calls—and the potential effect the new instant replay rules going into effect next year might have had. A force play by the Cardinals in Game 1 was correctly overturned by the umpiring crew, but the unprecedented reversal left St. Louis frustrated and MLB officials counting the days until the start of the new "manager challenge" system. Other moments—including a seventh-inning play at the plate Monday night—begged for the relative certainty of instant replay but were left to the umpires' on-field discretion instead.

Baseball has lagged woefully behind other North American sports leagues in stepping into the 21st century and adopting a comprehensive replay system. The NFL's current format has been in place since 1999, and NBA officials routinely review objective calls in the final two minutes of the fourth quarter. But as of now, blatant umpire screwups like the one that cost Armando Galarraga a perfect game in 2011 cannot be reviewed, even if television viewers at home see immediately (and usually repeatedly) that the call is wrong.

The umpire who messed up Galarraga's historic moment, veteran Jim Joyce, was actually on the third-base bag in the waning moments of Game 3 and made the obstruction ruling that ended the game, a gutsy and ultimately correct call. But when umps like Joyce do "kick the shit" out of a call, replay must exist to protect the integrity of the game and save the men in blue from Don Denkinger's fate. Thank goodness it's coming next season.

What do you think of the series so far guys? Are you excited about the coming expansion of instant replay? And how cool is David Ross's salt-and-pepper beard?


Stevens: Jake, you almost lost me at Don Denkinger. That famously blown call in the 1985 World Series was, after all, a key factor in my beloved Royals winning their only series title. I'll even admit there's a certain archaic joy in the possibility of blown calls affecting a game. Jeffrey Maier gifting Derek Jeter a homer in 1996 comes to mind. Sports are about entertainment, and truly screwed-up officiating like that gives us all something to talk about.

But, nah. 

Take last night. The Red Sox sent David Ross home on Jacoby Ellsbury’s single. At the plate, Ross seemed to evade Yadier Molina's tag, but was nevertheless punched out by home plate umpire Bill Miller. That's the current math of baseball. If the ball beats the player to the bag, he's generally going to be called out—whether he evades the tag or not. That's just wrong.

Purists might argue that instant replay will take away some of what make the game unique. Maybe. But unique isn't always good. My problem with replay is that it doesn't go far enough. What bugs me about the new system is that it's left up to managerial discretion. Like the NFL with its silly red flags, it will be left up to a manager to decide which possibly blown call needs to be challenged. Managers will be allowed one challenge in the first six innings and two more from the seventh to the end of the game. Dumb. Jake, you mentioned the missed call that ruined Galarraga's potential perfecto. Even if the new replay system had been in place, it's easy to imagine a situation where Jim Leyland would have had no challenges left by the ninth. The bad call might still have stood. Why go there? If we have the technology to eliminate bad calls, let's eliminate them. Every single call on the field should be reviewed, every time.

Presented by

Sports Roundtable

Patrick Hruby, Jake Simpson, and Hampton Stevens 

How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well. Bestselling author Mark Bittman teaches James Hamblin the recipe that everyone is Googling.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well.

Video

Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.

Video

The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.

Video

Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.

Video

Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses

Video

Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

More in Entertainment

Just In