How to End Baseball's Epic Officiating Screwups: Use Instant-Replay Umpires

The Oakland Athletics' overruled home run this week shows again that subjective on-field rulings are an unreliable, often unfair way to officiate MLB games.
banner oakland homer.jpg
AP / Mark Duncan

Inaccuracy is inevitable in a game with as many intricacies as baseball. Balls will be called strikes, checked swings will be debated, and the infield fly rule will confound fans forever. But one of the goals of Major League Baseball is to ensure the game is officiated as correctly as possible and offer an effective in-game remedy for the human mistakes of umpires. Wednesday night's debacle at Cleveland's Progressive Field showed once again that the MLB is failing at that goal.

With two outs in the ninth inning between the Athletics and the Indians, Oakland infielder Adam Rosales hit a game-tying home run that was incorrectly ruled a double on the field. The ruling was upheld even after four umpires, including crew chief Angel Hernandez, reviewed the replay.

That's the short version of the Catastrophe in Cleveland. The larger takeaway is that baseball's instant-replay system, introduced in 2008 to prevent the type of missed call that occurred on Wednesday, is not working. Baseball needs a replay umpire, or more games will be decided by human error.

It's still unclear how exactly Hernandez and his crew missed what everyone in the stadium—including both teams, both sets of announcers, and everyone in the press box—clearly saw. Rosales's hit bounced off the railing about nine inches above the yellow home-run line at the top of the padded wall in left field and ricocheted back onto the outfield grass. That couldn't have happened had the hit not been a home run, because the ball would have hit the soft padding below the line. After the game, Hernandez told a reporter that the crew did not believe there was "100 percent certainty" to overrule the call on the field, which sounds ludicrous to anyone who's watched even one replay of the "double."

Joe Torre, the league's executive vice president of baseball operations, released a statement Thursday afternoon that unwittingly identified the basic problem with baseball's current replay system:

In the opinion of Angel Hernandez, who was last night's crew chief, there was not clear and convincing evidence to overturn the decision on the field. It was a judgment call, and as such, it stands as final.

Torre's statement, like the MLB's current rule book, conflates an objective fact with a subjective review. Whether a ball crossed the home-run line is an objective question, and a review system that allows subjectivity to so easily override objectivity is fatally flawed.

This isn't the first time in recent years that a game has been marred by inept umpiring that could not be properly reviewed. Armando Galarraga's perfect game on June 2, 2010, was ruined when first-base umpire Jim Joyce called the last out of the game safe. And after erroneously ruling that then-Yankee Nick Swisher left third base too soon in the 2009 American League Championship Series, umpire Tim McClelland said: "In my heart I thought he left too soon... after looking at replays, I'm not sure I believe the replay."

Presented by

Jake Simpson is a New York-based writer.

Things Not to Say to a Pregnant Woman

You don't have to tell her how big she is. You don't need to touch her belly.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Things Not to Say to a Pregnant Woman

You don't have to tell her how big she is. You don't need to touch her belly.

Video

Maine's Underground Street Art

"Graffiti is the farthest thing from anarchy."

Video

The Joy of Running in a Beautiful Place

A love letter to California's Marin Headlands

Video

'I Didn't Even Know What I Was Going Through'

A 17-year-old describes his struggles with depression.

Video

Google Street View, Transformed Into a Tiny Planet

A 360-degree tour of our world, made entirely from Google's panoramas

Video

The Farmer Who Won't Quit

A filmmaker returns to his hometown to profile the patriarch of a family farm

Video

Riding Unicycles in a Cave

"If you fall down and break your leg, there's no way out."

Video

Carrot: A Pitch-Perfect Satire of Tech

"It's not just a vegetable. It's what a vegetable should be."

More in Entertainment

Just In