Doctor Who's Girl-Women Weirdness

Fans of the BBC's time-traveler series are divided over the maybe-creepy portrayals of the Doctor's young female companions under showrunner Steven Moffat.
doctor who.jpg

By any tangible measure, Doctor Who has never risen higher. The ongoing saga of the Time Lord who uses his magic box, the TARDIS, to travel anywhen in time (though mostly to the years 1963-2013) and anywhere in space (though mostly to London) turns 50 years old this year. And the Doctor himself? Well, when 1200 years old you reach, look as good, you will not.

The pop-culture penetration of the show since its 2005 revival (the original run ended in 1989, and a 1996 TV-movie pilot flopped) is undeniable. The 2012 Christmas special "The Snowmen" was just short of being the highest-rated program in BBC America's history (behind only the 2012 premiere). The hype for Saturday's mid-season premiere episode, "The Bells of Saint John," has been fevered, both on the Internet and in print.

So, why are some fans a bit apprehensive about where Doctor Who is headed? Like the show itself, it's all about the relationship between the Doctor and his companion.

The conceit of Doctor Who is one of incredible flexibility and power. With his ability to "regenerate" into different actors while remaining the same character—there have been 11 versions since the series started in 1963—the Doctor can be any kind of fantastical figure you want. Sometimes he's Peter Pan, sometimes he's James Bond, sometimes he's, as the Eleventh Doctor describes himself, "Space Gandalf."

But the true genius of the show is the constant presence of a viewer surrogate: the companion. The Doctor almost always has at least one inexperienced time-traveler (usually human, usually a woman) aboard to ask him what planet they're on, what that button is for, why is that stuntman wrapped in green spray-painted bubble wrap, and how in the world am I supposed to pretend to be scared of him?

The Doctor also is Torn Between Two Worlds. He's an alien who's always hanging around humans and deeply cares about them, but will always be distant because of his Otherness. "I suppose, in the end, they break my heart," David Tennant's Tenth Doctor says. And yet he always comes back to them. Desperately groping for a connection—for family.

It's this heart-wrenching blend of intimacy and distance, of possibility and inevitability that make the show so uniquely engaging. The constantly changing actors playing the same character, along with a rotating cast of companions, is also unique in pop culture, and engenders an unrivaled level of fan passion and investment in the characters. Everybody has a favorite Doctor and a favorite companion, and everybody has suggestions for who the next Doctor should be and what kinds of adventures he—or she (it's really about time)—should have.

With former showrunner Russell T. Davies's relaunch of the series, he put an even finer point on the Doctor's loneliness: The Doctor is now the only Time Lord left, having destroyed both his own people and their mortal enemies the Daleks in the Last Great Time War. So, now he's Superman, too, only with more guilt and PTSD.

Davies's run has its critics, featuring as it did more than a handful of clunker episodes and melodramatic finales that leaned too heavily on people gaining godlike powers in the third act. But he managed to give both the Doctor and his companions satisfying character arcs, and the inevitable lachrymose farewells nearly always felt earned.

When Steven Moffat took over in 2010, introducing a new regeneration of the Doctor, played by Matt Smith, a lot of fans were thrilled. Moffat's episodes during Davies's tenure are consensus top-10 picks for the best episodes of the Davies years, if not ever.

Now, though, in the third full season with Moffat at the helm, what some viewers saw as troubling tendencies from those early episodes have multiplied. Television Without Pity recapper Jacob Clifton went so far as to say that Davies's Who is "a different TV show that shares basically a title and a prop" with the Moffat incarnation. Indeed, Moffat-vs.-RTD is the biggest Whovians-yelling-at-one-another-on-the-Internet fault line. (New Who vs. Classic Who debates tend to be courtly by comparison.)

Like any writer, Moffat has his pet themes and plot devices. His favorites mostly have to do with perception, memory, and the power of story. The Weeping Angels can only move when you're not looking at them. You can only remember the Silence while you're looking at them. Companion Amy Pond rebooted the entire universe simply by remembering it. His tendency to recycle ideas has prompted more than a few parodies; Moffat Bingo is my favorite.

Presented by

Ted B. Kissell is a writer and editor based in Southern California. He is the former editor of OC Weekly and has written for The Los Angeles TimesOutside Traveler, and American Way.

How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well. Bestselling author Mark Bittman teaches James Hamblin the recipe that everyone is Googling.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well.


Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.


The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.


Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.


Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

More in Entertainment

Just In