The Never-Ending Debate Over Women in Metal and Hard Rock

Revolver magazine's annual "hottest chicks" issue shows that females are seen as a novelty in heavy music. That's a problem.

revolver hot chicks in hard rock 615.jpg

Heavy metal has been a boys' club since before Tony Iommi famously severed his fingertips and summoned forth the thunderous, primeval black magic that fans hold so dear. The hyper-masculine, sweat-drenched, ear-splitting world created by the unholy trinity of Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, and Iron Maiden seemingly held little room for women's voices, but that doesn't mean there haven't been any. They've just had to scream just a little louder to be heard. Thankfully, much has changed on that front since 1979, when Girlschool first played with Motorhead, and since 1982, when Warlock's Teutonic metal goddess Doro Pesch first wailed her way into the hearts (and onto the bedroom walls) of metal fans the world over.

Today, female metal heads run labels, magazines, booking agencies, venues, recording studios, law firms, merchandising companies, websites, publicity firms, distros, pressing plants, and record stores. They shred. They scream. They pound the drums, they hold down the low end, they throw up the horns. They hail Satan and shout at the Devil. It's with this in mind that heavy metal fans gear up every year to engage in a now-annual debate with Revolver Magazine over their Hottest Chicks in Metal issue, renamed this year to be the Hottest Chicks in Hard Rock.

Women don't get involved in metal to be ogled

The idea is simple enough. Each year, Revolver publishes a collection of features focused on female bands and band members (and often more inexplicable choices, like tattoo artists or actresses) replete with lots of big pictures splashed across its pages. Ostensibly, the goal is to provide exposure to the women of metal, and celebrate them for their talent and brains as well as their beauty—think Miss America's "scholarship" competitions with less world peace and more devil horns. But the ladies' musical backgrounds and achievements often play second fiddle to their luminous cheekbones or dangerous curves.

It usually ends up as Revolver's highest grossing and most popular issue of the year. That doesn't mean everyone likes it. Critics—I'm among them—ask why it is that the magazine sees the need to put together a "special edition" once every 12 months, instead of choosing to allocate equal coverage to start with. Revolver seldom gives in-depth coverage to female musicians or bands during the rest of the year; the women are almost always relegated to the now-regular "Hottest Chicks in Metal" one-page feature that graces each issue. The insistence upon segregation, separation, and sexuality has plenty of feminists baying for blood.

Gazelle Amber Valentine of experimental doom duo Jucifer posted a series of tweets that sum up the gripes: "Singling out females for a special implies we can't equal men. Focusing on 'hotness' implies that it's okay to judge us for that alone ... I want to live in a world where nobody gets more or less because of traits they're born with. ALL women are hot. It's not an accomplishment. Why not value real ability and contributions?"

This year, the controversy has been loud enough that editor Brandon Geist has shot back, diving into Twitter discussions (including a running argument with Valentine, as well as with a number of female metal fans) and posting an open letter of rebuttal to the chorus of haters, outlining a handful of valid arguments as well as baiting his critics once again.

One of his most thought-provoking points: "To my mind, it is extremely condescending to the women involved to act as if YOU know better than they do what is right for THEM. A lot of women consider it to be a compliment to be asked to be part of the issue. A lot of women like to feel sexy, dress sexy, and be photographed looking sexy. A lot of women lobbied vigorously for their inclusion in the issue (and, historically, some girls have been approached and declined to participate, and we've always respected that choice)... Now, you could respond that the women who want to be in the issue have clearly been brainwashed by a paternalistic society into thinking that the only way they will be valued and gain attention is to use their physical appearances. Or you could respond that these girls have sold out, allowing themselves to be exploited and using their physical appearances as promotional tools to get their music/bands out there. But, first off, who are you to divine what their motives are? And secondly, when you make such claims, aren't YOU the one demeaning these women?"

Geist seems more than a little defensive here. I'd argue he ignores the greater problem—that of the portrayal of female musicians within the metal/rock media—and instead attempts to assign blame to feminists and other concerned detractors of the magazine by accusing them of misogyny and condescension. He ends with, "Really all we're trying to do is put out a fun issue that spotlights some rad female musicians without taking ourselves too seriously and getting all didactic 'Women in Rock' on anyone. But again, if you wanna get your panties all in a bunch about it, that's fun to watch, too." Plenty of panties (and more than a few pairs of boxers) are still bunched up over this issue, and the one-two punch of blaming others and trivializing the problem did little to endear Geist to his critics.

Presented by

Kim Kelly is a New York-based writer and music journalist. She has written about heavy metal and the culture surrounding it for The Guardian, Pitchfork, and NPR. She blogs at Necrolust.

How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well. Bestselling author Mark Bittman teaches James Hamblin the recipe that everyone is Googling.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


How to Cook Spaghetti Squash (and Why)

Cooking for yourself is one of the surest ways to eat well.


Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.


The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.


Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.


Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

More in Entertainment

Just In