Books July/August 2006 Atlantic Monthly

Finds and flops

by Elizabeth Judd

New Fiction

Article Tools

E-mail Article
Printer Format

In her stupendously wise and very funny seventeenth novel, Anne Tyler tackles the ambitious subject of national character without leaving the confines of Baltimore. At the airport, two Korean infants are delivered to two eagerly awaiting adoptive families: Ziba and Sami Yazdan, a prosperous Iranian-American couple, and Bitsy and Brad Donaldson, who wait with “flotillas of silvery balloons” and a boisterous entourage of relatives bearing video cameras. Enamored of all things foreign, Bitsy befriends the Yazdans only to impose on both households a well- intentioned but hokey vision of multiculturalism, dressing daughter Jin-Ho in a sagusam and chiding Ziba for “Americanizing” baby Susan’s hairstyle. Tyler captures an essential quality of the international adoption experience—the girls’ unfathomable backgrounds transform even fashion decisions into deeply symbolic acts, subject to earnest debate.

The first half of Digging to America consists almost entirely of folksy social commentary; Tyler delineates her characters’ foibles with such tender equanimity that this peevish reader longed for a touch of venom. Gradually, though, Sami’s mother, Maryam, emerges as the novel’s governing intelligence in a nuanced portrait of immigrant life (Tyler was married to the late Taghi Modarressi, an Iranian-American psychiatrist), and the saccharine element disappears. Maryam claims onlooker status to distance herself from the blithering Donaldsons and to dodge the advances of Bitsy’s widowed father, but her aloofness is really ontological, an innate standoffishness familiar to Tyler’s readers. Tyler, who was raised among various Quaker communities and who turned eleven before she first used a telephone, understands the powerful magic of self-imposed isolation like no other writer publishing today. Digging to America succeeds on many levels—as a satire of millennial parenting, a tribute to autumn romances, and, most important, an exploration of our risible (though poignant) attempts to welcome otherness into our midst.

Digging to America

by Anne Tyler
Knopf

Elizabeth Judd is a writer in Washington, D.C.

Article Tools

E-mail Article
Printer Format

What do you think? Discuss this article in Post & Riposte.

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter.

Also By

Elizabeth Judd

September 2006

New Fiction

The Emperor's Children, by Claire Messud.

June 2006

Finds and flops

The Man of My Dreams, by Curtis Sittenfeld.

May 2006

New Fiction

The Whole World Over, by Julia Glass.


Name

Address 1

Address 2

City

State Zip

Email

Atlantic Voices

It Would Help In Kentucky Read more

13 May 2008 08:50 A.M.

Home Court Redux Read more

13 May 2008 08:42 A.M.

Clash of the Titans ... Read more

12 May 2008 5:10 P.M.

Food, glorious food . . . Read more

13 May 2008 07:19 A.M.

Republicans "Sore" At Obama's Metahpor Read more

12 May 2008 8:24 P.M.

Earthquake accounts from foreigners in Chengdu Read more

13 May 2008 03:42 A.M.

The Honorable Mr. Boehner Read more

13 May 2008 12:02 A.M.

Pause Read more

02 May 2008 7:21 P.M.