Skip Navigation

The Daily Dish - 2006-2011 archives for The Daily Dish, featuring Andrew Sullivan

Why Not Statehood For DC?

By The Daily Dish
Apr 22 2010, 3:58 AM ET

The DC voting rights bill died again earlier this week. Bernstein asks:

I still don't understand why the Democrats didn't just push through DC statehood while they had the chance, during the brief period in which they had 60 votes in the Senate.

Yes, there are a host of practical problems. The tax base is pretty slim: federal offices and non-profits, which DC has an abundance of, aren't going to bring in enough (or any) revenue. Here's a decent, if somewhat old, summary of the economic problems DC would face as a full fledged state. Joyner's solution:

As I’ve noted several times in the past, my personal preference would be retrocession, whether real or virtual. Essentially, giving DC minus the Bernstein carveout back to Maryland. That solves the problem of giving the District’s residents representation in Congress which I absolutely believe they deserve and yet not giving them the ridiculously outsized power that would come from statehood.

Just why, pray, is giving the 600,000 people who live in DC proper representation in the Congress granting us a "ridiculously outsized power." You mean: unlike North Dakota (pop. 650,000) or Alaska (pop. 700,000)? There is simply no way to justify spending trillions to bring "democracy" to Baghdad, while refusing to grant it to America's capital city. In fact, the US - because of this anachronism - is the only advanced democracy to bar the citizens of its own capital from having the franchise. I think this simple fact outweighs any practical argument whatever.



Presented by

More at The Atlantic

translating the Bible—Into an E-Book That Works on Any Phone Translating the Bible—Into an E-Book That Works on Any Phone
Video Shows Syrian Anti-Aircraft Tank Firing Randomly Into Peoples' Homes Video Shows Syrian Anti-Aircraft Tank Firing Into Random Homes
The Myth of Energy Independence: Why We Can't Drill Our Way to Oil Autonomy Why We Can't Drill Our Way to Oil Autonomy
SNL's Zooey Deschanel Episode: 5 Best Scenes The 5 Funniest Sketches From SNL's Zooey Deschanel Episode
Why Does Maine Have a Two-and-a-Half-Month Caucus? Mitt Romney Wins Maine's Two-and-a-Half-Month Caucus
Special Report
Election 2012 Reuters Election 2012
The destination for full politics coverage, from the primaries to the White House. Read more ›
View All Correspondents

The Biggest Story in Photos

The Civil War, Part 3: The Stereographs

Feb 10, 2012

Subscribe Now

SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY

Facebook

Newsletters

Sign up to receive our free newsletters

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)