Skip Navigation

The Daily Dish - 2006-2011 archives for The Daily Dish, featuring Andrew Sullivan

Neoconservatism and Iran

By The Daily Dish
Nov 21 2007, 7:32 AM ET

A reader writes:

The fundamental premise of the neocon argument for attacking Iran is based on two concepts:

1. A nuclear armed Iran, even with a single weapon and little means to deliver it, is a fundamental threat to our nation that cannot be permitted

2. A military strike against Iran will stop them from being able to make a nuclear weapon.

I will grant that, assuming such a strike did in fact wipe out all of Iran's nuclear facilities, on the day after that attack, Iran would find themselves unable to make a nuclear weapon.  What happens on day two?  Day 10?  Day 1000?  Would Iran be progressing towards liberal democracy?  No.  Would Iran have less motivation to possess a nuclear weapon?  No.  Quite the opposite, they'd have indisputable evidence that they were vulnerable and that having a nuclear trump card was vital to their security.

In a neocon world, time stops after we attack. Unfortunately for all of us, they are living in our world, not theirs.

And what if Putin or a future Pakistani leader decides just to give them one anyway, in solidarity after US aggression? I understand the worry about Iran's regime and nukes. It's real. But pretending that no other global powers exist or that mere bombing will solve our fundamental problem with Islamism seems to me to be badly short-sighted.



Presented by

More at The Atlantic

Romney's Plan to Save Higher Ed: Let the Private Sector Handle It Romney's Plan to Save Higher Ed
Does the Supreme Court Believe in Double Jeopardy Protections? Does the Supreme Court Believe in Double Jeopardy Protections?
A False Photo From a Real Massacre A False Photo of a Real Massacre
The Brash Hypocrisy of Lanny Davis This Man Represents Everything Wrong in Washington
The Color, Romance, and Impact of the Golden Gate at 75 America's Most Famous Bridge Turns 75
View All Correspondents

The Biggest Story in Photos

Where in the World? Part 3: A Google Earth Puzzle

May 25, 2012

Subscribe Now

SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY

Facebook

Newsletters

Sign up to receive our free newsletters

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)