Do Atheists Envy Christians?

Or are they just condescending? Ross and Matt debate it. I must say I always thought that Karl Rove at least pretended to be a born-again. Fred Barnes wrote in "Triumph of the Will" "Rebel-In-Chief" that:

Bush has surrounded himself in the White House with fellow Christians. His four most influential advisers - Rove, Gerson, Cheney and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice - share his faith.

Who knows Rove's religion best, do you think? Fred or Hitch?