Private Mortgage Modifications Overshadow Government Program

If you follow the struggles of the government's "HAMP" foreclosure prevention effort, then you might think modifying mortgages is a lost cause. Last month, five times as many homeowners dropped out of HAMP than obtained permanent modifications. Its numbers of new trials and permanent modifications both declined in May. But there might be a reason why it's doing so badly: more attractive private servicer modification programs are crowding out the need for government assistance.

The House Committee for Oversight and Government Reform held another hearing on HAMP on Thursday. Representatives from five major mortgage servicers testified. In one part of the hearing, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) asked what portion of their total mortgage modifications were permanent HAMP modifications (see bottom of post for video clip). The results weren't pretty:

HAMP oversight stats 2010-06.bmp

As you can see, the vast majority of the time borrowers are choosing private modification programs over HAMP. Jordan followed up, asking whether there were many borrowers who qualified for HAMP but would not their program. All panelists said that this was a rare situation. In fact, some indicated that they often successfully modify mortgages for borrowers who didn't even qualify for HAMP. Here are a few choice responses.

Sanjiv Das, Chief Executive Officer, CitiMortgage, Inc.:

"Let's put it this way, for the people who fell out of HAMP, we were able to save about 15% more."

Michael J. Heid, Co-President, Wells Fargo Home Mortgage:

"Somewhere between 70 and 80 percent of the HAMP cancellations are resulting in some other form of saving the home or avoiding foreclosure."

Jordan drew the conclusion that HAMP was probably unnecessary to begin with. If almost all of the strikingly few borrowers that the program has helped would have qualified for private modifications anyway, what was the point? That doesn't sound like $75 billion well-spent.

While that line of reasoning is appears sensible, there is another side to the argument. The government's insistence on mortgage modification and creation of HAMP might have driven private programs to succeed as well. Once these servicers realized they would be forced to participate in HAMP, due to their acceptance of bailout money, they devised their own proprietary modification programs instead. In this case, it's possible that HAMP's existence helped to create the private mortgage modification market.

Even if it did, however, $75 billion is a pretty big price tag for nudging along a private sector that may have ended up in the same place anyway. The statistics above don't speak very favorably about HAMP's design either. The government program provides carrots to servicers, investors, and borrowers for their participation, but still produces far worse results than private programs without any such incentives.


Presented by

Daniel Indiviglio was an associate editor at The Atlantic from 2009 through 2011. He is now the Washington, D.C.-based columnist for Reuters Breakingviews. He is also a 2011 Robert Novak Journalism Fellow through the Phillips Foundation. More

Indiviglio has also written for Forbes. Prior to becoming a journalist, he spent several years working as an investment banker and a consultant.

Why Is Google Making Human Skin?

Hidden away on Google’s campus, doctors at a world-class life sciences lab are trying to change the way people think about their health.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Videos

Why Is Google Making Human Skin?

Hidden away on Google’s campus, doctors are changing the way people think about health.

Video

How to Build a Tornado

A Canadian inventor believes his tornado machine could solve the world's energy crisis.

Video

A New York City Minute, Frozen in Time

This short film takes you on a whirling tour of the Big Apple

Video

What Happened to the Milky Way?

Light pollution has taken away our ability to see the stars. Can we save the night sky?

Video

The Pentagon's $1.5 Trillion Mistake

The F-35 fighter jet was supposed to do everything. Instead, it can barely do anything.

More in Business

Just In