Political Theory

More

Obama's poll numbers have been improving steadily over the last week.  Theory:  people like Democrats much better when they are not talking about health care.  Corollary:  the liberal commentators saying that no, really, health care is in a good position to pass are indulging in wishful thinking.  (To be sure, it is possible to level exactly the same accusation at me).

The Townhall ruckuses were not the end of the Republican opposition on health care.  They were the beginning.  There is an observed regularity in politics so consistent that I am tempted to dub it Megan's First Law of Politics:  intentions are more popular than concrete proposals.  As long as there was no one Obama Plan on the table, people could project their fondest dreams onto the president.  Once there are plans on the table, Republicans will be able to attack specific propositions that are specifically attached to the president.

For example, polling last year found that a majority of Democratic primary voters were opposed to a mandate to buy health care.  Mandates were popular among two groups:  people with post-graduate education, and people who made more than $100K.  Polls this year are a little more positive--but people aren't paying attention to the details of the debate right now.  I'm betting that support for mandates drops once people aren't hearing about them for the first time from a pollster.  When someone asks you, "Should people have to buy health insurance?", if you haven't really thought about the question, your answer is likely to be different--and more positive--than it will be after you've been musing on the oppo ads for a while.  

Moreover, this mandate will come with a specific price tag on the subsidies, not a fuzzy "should people have to buy health insurance" question.  Republicans will be able to find plenty of people who are going to be forced to buy insurance that they can't really afford under the new plan, or taxed heavily for their failure to comply.  Even worse, these people will be easier to identify with than the uninsured:  at or above the nation's median household income, possibly living in a high-cost area.  The lower Democrats cut the subsidies to make the price tag politically powerful, the more dramatic the sob stories will be.

This is not the only problem area.  The budget deficit is big enough--and projected to stay big enough--that people are starting to care about it again.  All of the plans on the table at this point stay deficit neutral only because the program doesn't kick in for four years; after that window, the costs explode.  Most of the plans are similar enough to what prevails in Massachussetts that Republicans can reasonably point to the runaway costs there.

Once there is a specific plan to make any cuts at all to Medicare, seniors will go ballistic.

. . . and so on, ad infinitum.  Health care reform has not survived the worst Republicans can throw at it.  It's survived--barely--the opening volley.

Jump to comments

Megan McArdle is a former writer and editor at The Atlantic.

Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)


Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Miami: The Next Big Start-Up City?

How the city became a center for innovation

Video

Video

A Brief History of Romantic Comedies

From The Atlantic's Chris Orr

Video

Video

Life in 'the New Arctic'

A moving portrait of a fading landscape

Video

Video

The Rise of New York City

A fascinating look at Manhattan in the 1940s

Video

'I Thought It Was Really Funny, but No One Else Did'

A day with New Yorker cartoonist Joe Dator

Video

New Yorkers: The Winemaker

Make your own wine ... in New York City

Video

What Is Methane Hydrate?

"Flaming ice" is a vast natural energy source

Video

NASA's Time-Lapse of the Sun

Now with epic dubstep music

Video

A Video Letter From the Editor

Highlights from the May 2013 issue

Video

Shaken Not Tuned: Cocktail Experiments

Can a tuning fork improve a cocktail?

Video

Video

The Rise of Environmentalism

Tracking 50 years, from the Love Canal disaster to Greenpeace

Video

Is He Cheating? A 1950s Guide

'That little blonde secretary from the office?’

Video

New Yorkers: Vintage Vacuum-Tube Amps

Risking electric shock to restore old amplifiers

Video

The DIY Piano-Bicycle

Everybody needs a hobby

Writers

Up
Down

More in Business

In Focus

2013 National Geographic Traveler Photo Contest

Just In