Skip Navigation

Jim Manzi More

Jim Manzi is Founder and Chairman of Applied Predictive Technologies (APT), an applied artificial intelligence software company. He is In also a Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a Contributing Editor of National Review, where he writes frequently for both the print and online editions on topics related to science, technology, business and economics.

Do political actions affect economic growth?

By Jim Manzi
Feb 3 2009, 8:23 PM ET Comment

Last week, Steven Landsburg pointed to a striking chart that shows remarkable stability in the growth rate of US GDP per capita over two centuries. I've pointed to a version of this chart myself as a source of rational confidence about our economic future, at least in the long-term. But I think that Landsburg was bit Panglossian when he explains the cause of this as:

It's the way the modern world works. Things improve. Incomes rise, work hours fall, the quality of goods improves. 

Consider the growth of computational power per year over the past 50 years or so. It has followed a path of consistent exponential growth that is remarkably similar:



mooreslaw.jpg


This is just a graphical representation of Moore's Law, the famous observation that the number of transistors per integrated circuit doubles roughly every two years. This is the foundation for the iPhones and Kindles that Landsburg references, and one important driver of growth in GDP per capita over the past few decades.


This hasn't just happened. It has taken tens of thousands of lifetimes of work by some of the world's smartest engineers, constant business model changes, disruptions to lives and communities, and so on. All of the intellectual work, corporate policy changes and so on that have created this have not just been sound and light around the "real" process of innovation; they have been what has created the growth.


In the same way, it's not so obvious that all of the political turmoil, changes to institutions, laws and mores, and so on that have constituted the substance of modern politics are just sound and light around the "real" process of economic growth.


What I think Landsburg fails to address is the level of abstraction at which some hypothetical stable process operates that generates this stable growth rate. By example, one could argue that something like "entrepreneurial capitalism with deep investment in research universities" is the stable process that creates Moore's Law. In this way, the changes like "Andy Grove replaces the Intel manufacturing head and institutes a new manufacturing strategy" or "Stanford changes its rules for faculty ownership of patent rights" aren't empty and unimportant, but are in fact the necessary changes that the stable underlying process forces in order to maintain growth in processing power.


In the same way, if the underlying process that has generated stable growth in GDP per capita is something like "modern capitalism, rule of law and a high-trust society" (or whatever - I'm not claiming I have a succinct definition of this underlying process), and the mechanisms that this process uses to maintain economic growth are things like changes in levels of presidential authority or types of business regulation or tax rates and so on, it doesn't follow at all that "the last president didn't have much to do with" economic growth.


In other words, success of broad politico-economic system doesn't imply that all of the actual work that goes on within it is pointless.

Presented by

More at The Atlantic

3 Signs China May Be Ready to Innovate Is China Ready to Innovate?
Why Older Americans Have the Worst Long-Term Unemployment Crisis Why Older People Have the Worst Job Crisis
The Fastest-Dying Jobs of This Generation (and What Replaced Them) The Fastest-Dying Jobs of This Generation
Bubbles Are the Super-Rich's Best Friend Bubbles Are the 1%'s Best Friend
The Unanswered Questions About America's Escalating Fight in Yemen 4 Questions for America's Escalating Fight in Yemen

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Special Report
Capitals of the Connected World The Atlantic Capitals of the Connected World
Mapping the new global power structure—an Atlantic special report Read more ›
View All Correspondents

The Biggest Story in Photos

Star City and the Baikonur Cosmodrome

May 15, 2012

Subscribe Now

SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY

Facebook

Newsletters

Sign up to receive our free newsletters

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)

(sample)